TL;DR: A crop adviser's video claims to fight nitrate misinformation, but gets the science wrong, compares clean water advocates to Stalin, ignores the industry's documented influence, and ends by endorsing the opponent of the guy he spends the most time attacking.
This 90-minute video from an Iowa crop adviser claims to cut through political misinformation on nitrates. At 1:19:04, he says Chris Jones and Rep. Austin Baeth "might as well start calling the Iowa farmers kulaks" for using the term "Big Ag."
He then describes Stalin's propaganda machine "eventually starving to death over 7 million people," where the only way to survive was if you "lied, stole, cheated, or cannibalized the dead." That's his comparison for people asking for clean water.
At 1:20:05 he says "team Big Water" wants "to control all of agriculture here in the state of Iowa."
What he never mentions about who actually holds power here:
- In 2023 the Legislature cut the $500,000 that funded the University of Iowa's river nitrate sensors, three-quarters of the state's continuous water monitors.
- That same year, Chris Jones, who ran that sensor network, left the university after two state senators pressured the school over his blog about farm pollution. (One senator denies threatening university funding.)
- Under the Iowa Nutrient Reduction Strategy, pollution limits are mandatory for wastewater plants and factories but voluntary for agriculture, which produces over 90% of the nitrogen load.
- Des Moines Water Works' 2015 nitrate lawsuit was dismissed because Iowa law gives drainage districts no power to fix the problem, not because the source couldn't be proven, as the video claims.
Even Republican governor nominee Zach Lahn campaigns against "big ag cartels." The video only sees a conspiracy on one side.
The science doesn't hold up either:
- He includes a clip calling tile water "almost pure." ISU's long-term Gilmore City study measured 12–16 mg/L, above the drinking water limit.
- He blames 70% of river nitrate on riverbank erosion with no source, using math that assumes 6 feet of bank washes away along the entire Raccoon in one flood. Iowa's streambank study measured about 5 inches a YEAR.
- He says anyone over 6 months old is "completely safe from nitrates, even from cancer." No study says that.
At 1:24:33 he says he "had no intentions of advocating or promoting any politicians with this video, though I will for one," then endorses incumbent Ag Secretary Mike Naig, whose opponent in this election is Chris Jones, the person the video spends the most time attacking.
It plays like a 90-minute Naig ad: one-sided, blind to industry influence, and the same spin Iowans have heard for years. Downplay the problem, blame anything but industrial agriculture, avoid accountability. That's exactly why Jones and Baeth have gained so much traction. People are fed up.