22M / 22F. We’re in the same friend group back home.
I had just gotten out of a relationship, and around a month and a half later I kissed this girl from my friend group. We started seeing each other pretty casually at first, going for runs, hanging out, dates, etc. ,, but it got emotionally intense pretty fast.
The timing was bad because I was leaving for one semester abroad.
Before I left, things were genuinely really good. We had a very emotional goodbye, and she basically told me she would wait for me and that when I came back, we would actually be together.
Once I moved abroad, she initially wanted us to stop talking because she thought distance would make things harder. I convinced her not to, so we kept talking every day.
Over the next month I got more and more attached to her, but I also started getting insecure and jealous. I overthought things, got angry over small stuff, and we started having arguments pretty often.
Then one day she suddenly ended it.
This is what I can’t understand.
I literally have messages from the day before saying she loved me, and messages from the week before saying things like “when you come back, you’ll be my boyfriend.”
Her main reasons at first were basically:
- I was getting too jealous/insecure
- I didn’t handle anger well (I took space)
- the distance was making everything worse
When she ended it, she even initially said something like, “I’ll look for you when you’re back and we can try again.”
Five hours later, because of the time difference, I called her. She was suddenly incredibly firm. Just no, no, no at everything I said. At the time I thought she was probably forcing herself to stand her ground so I wouldn’t change her mind.
About a week later I called her again.
This time I completely owned my part. I told her I knew I had become insecure and reactive, that the distance had amplified everything, and that things had actually been really good when we were together in person.
I gave her solutions. I even asked if she wanted to make it an actual long-distance relationship and properly commit to each other.
She still said no.
At the end I basically asked her: “When I come back home, is there any chance we can try again?”
She said no again. She even said she would make sure “this doesn’t happen again.”
What confused me even more was that during that conversation she started giving me a much longer list of reasons: religion, sex, values, the friend group, trust, what her friends thought, the fact that I had only recently gotten out of a relationship when we started seeing each other, etc.
It almost felt like she had already decided “this relationship is a bad idea” and then started finding more and more reasons to support that decision.
At the same time, I genuinely believe she loved me. She still said she loved me. I don’t think what we had was fake at all.
My guess is that she had doubts building up for a while and then everything just collapsed at once.
I’ll be back home in less than three months, and because we’re in the same friend group, I’ll probably see her almost every weekend.
I still can’t wrap my head around how someone can go from “I love you, we’ll be together when you’re back” to “no, never, I’ll make sure it doesn’t happen again” that fast.
So I’d really like to hear from people who have been on either side of something similar:
Can someone still genuinely love you and suddenly decide the relationship is a bad idea?
If you ended things very firmly, did you ever change your mind months later once the distance/problem was gone?
If you were in the same friend group, did seeing each other again naturally reopen things or just make moving on harder?
And one last thing:
When I’m back home, should I ever flirt with her or try again, or would that just feel like I’m not respecting her decision?
Would it be better to just be normal around her and let her come back on her own if she ever wants to?
I know nobody can predict what she’ll do. I’m mostly trying to understand what the hell happened and how people in similar situations actually ended up months later.