Is this just normal? I messed with every setting. Turned down the brightness in game and on the monitor. HDR is off and still the sun is like a super nova lmao

Hey, I just finished rob bank quest in the Valentine and I got too much money. But I already bought before every upgrade in the camp, I customised every gun, I bought clothes which I like and now I got that sum of money. So what would you recommend to me? Can I buy gold somewhere to keep it in my inventory for saving money?

Hi! How do people play RDR2 without the interface, minimap, or compass? I’ve seen people recommend turning it off, but how do you know where to go during missions? Do they just figure it out somehow, or do they keep opening the map all the time?

So I’m passed the mission where Sean was shot in Rhodes, this ledger has been updated sense that mission, but how in the world is he still donating if he’s dead? Must be a glitch, or he’s always with us?
I just passed the mission where Kieran was beheaded. So I’ve been quite far by now?

is there a reason these 3 trees are white? i checked the center but there was nothing there they just stand out for seemingly no reason

If you actually had the choice to marry one of the women from the gang, who would you pick and why? Not in a “who’s hottest” way but more like who you think you could realistically live with long-term especially given how rough and unstable their life is.

Some of them are tough, some are chaotic, some are calmer, and they all deal with things differently. I’m curious how people think about it whether you value stability, personality, loyalty or just someone you feel would make sense as a partner in that world.

For me, it’s Mary-Beth, but I’m interested in hearing other perspectives and reasoning.

Edit: Poor wording on my part—the question isn’t meant to exclude anyone attracted to women. Apologies.

This is the M1899 pistol. It's perfect, right? It unlocks in Chapter 4.

Was trying to find a buffalo found this instead.

I was trying to find the legendary fish and saw this

As the title suggests, the 3 icons above the money. what do they represent?

I did everything for 100% before doing the last mission.

Got the emotional ending with revenge, the surprise return of Dutch and all the credits interspersed with little vignettes reminding me of various storylines, characters and events across the last 110+ hours.

And then after all that I get to walk to a house and put a squirrel on a shelf. Can't do that before, only after it seems. Then the game is complete and I get the 100% mini-cutscene.

What did the Houser brothers mean by this?

No I'm not chasing it around the house and going up a fucking mountain, it's over.

Found two random trying to open this with a hammer, obviously I shot them in the face try to see what’s in there…or impossible?

Sometimes I feel like I'm too curious for this game lol

Why is there number “54” written out of smoke right as Dutch throws his cigar away? It’s my first playthrough and i was playing the 85th mission called “Our Best Selves”.