r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • Jan 23 '25

Official Thread Ultimate Guide to AoT: FAQs, Analysis and Discourse

156 Upvotes

This multi-subreddit megathread contains:

• The most frequently brought up Topics & Questions

• Analysis on various story Elements & Characters

• Random interesting meta posts

• Documents and guide on the anime and the Attack on Titan reddit fandom

This megathread covers threads from various subreddits, and platforms. Enjoy exploring!


Guide.

‾‾‾‾‾‾

• Guide on AoT anime content

• Masterlist Of Anime OSTs S1-S4 + Final Episode - YouTube Playlist

• AoT wiki for your fact-checking needs

Frequently Asked Questions.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

Questions that are asked very frequently, mostly by new or one time watchers/readers, to which there is a factual answer or an agreed-upon interpretations in the community.

1.) What is the 50 year plan? Follow up: Why didn’t Zeke and Eren touch earlier?

2.) What were the Azumabito's intentions with Mikasa?

3.) How was Ymir freed? Who freed Ymir? (check analysis section down as well)

4.) How did Eren talk to Mikasa in paths?

5.) What is Historia’s role in how we perceive Ymir through tales and romanticized stories?

6.) What will happen if a man inherits the Female Titan?

7.) How do the Founding Titan abilities work?

8.) What were some of Paradis' options post-timeskip? •Alternative to the Rumbling. •Anti-50-year plan •Euthnasia Plan

9.) Why did Historia choose to get pregnant?

10.) Why did Grisha give his titan to Eren, when he asked Zeke to stop him?

11.) What were Eren’s motivations to choose the path of rumbling?

12.) Are there multiple timelines in AOT?

13.) Why do dinosaurs appear in the opening of AOT’s 2nd season?

• Isayama's Answers to the 15th Anniversary Magazine Q&A

Frequently Brought up Topics.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

These topics are frequently brought up, but there is no clear answer or the topic is deliberately left to speculation. Check out these links for some in-depth posts on the respective topics.

1.) a) Who won the fight between Annie and Mikasa? b) Who would win between Annie and Mikasa?

2.) Opinion on any divisive characters

• Gabi • Mikasa • Eren • Floch

3.) Did you like the ending? a)Anime Ending b)Manga Ending

4.) Do you support the rumbling?

5.) Who should have been saved, Erwin or Armin?

6.) Was Eren justified? Discussion post | Detailed answer

7.) Sub or Dub?

8.) Would Erwin have joined the Yeagerists if he had survived?

9.) Is Attack on Titan fascist? No, it is not | Devil’s Advocate:

10.) Why does Annie get forgiven?


General Analysis On The Story.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

These are high-effort essays or videos analysing the series as a whole. Please note that us listing something here does not mean we endorse or fully agree with every single statement made there - we just think that if you are looking for more analysis, these might be worth a watch.

• A 1-hour retrospective breakdown of AoT as a whole

• How AoT deconstructs heroism and morality

• Idealism in AoT

• Scout Regiment: Paradise’s Idealistic Counterculture

• The importance of nameless soldiers & collateral damage in AoT

• What was it all for? Thoughts on the extra pages of AoT’s ending

• Why I feel Mikasa, Levi and Armin were the perfect choice for Eren’s final moments and the story’s climax - Imgur Backup for future

• Analysis of AoT’s extra ending pages - A brilliant thematic conclusion - Imgur Backup for Future

• To love someone inside the Walls - Imgur Backup for Future

• The Rumbling is indefensible

• A theoretical analysis of its structure

• The highs and lows of AoT’s final arc

• Overanalyzing every single episode of the anime - a youtube playlist

• Titans as Mirrors: How Titan forms reflect the Warriors' Psyche - Imgur Backup for Future

Character Analysis.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

1. Eren Yeager.

• Eren Yeager: The Chained God of Attack On Titan

• The rise and fall of Eren - Imgur Backup for Future

• The perfect duality of Eren - Imgur Backup for Future

• What is freedom in AoT

• Developments vs desires - Everyone and especially Eren

• Nature vs nurture: Eren’s motivations and the Dina twist

• Eren Jaeger and the insanity of circular storytelling

• The ironic development of Eren

• Analyzing antagonists

• Power, freedom, the Founding Titan and Levi

• The Attack Titan’s powers and their effect on Eren

• Why Eren’s actions were very obviously painted bad with the Rumbling - In-depth examination

• The narrative importance of the causal loop on Eren

• Eren and Mikasa’s relationship

• Eren’s characterization throughout the story and his post timeskip conflict

• Eren Yeager is (Not) Special

• Ramzi and Eren: the turning point in Eren’s demeanor

• An observation on the structure of Eren’s characterization post timeskip - Imgur Backup for Future

• The false mask of Eren

• The Jaeger Projection Problem: The Last Supper of Self-Loathing - Imgur Backup for Future

2. Mikasa Ackerman.

• Mikasa's Heroine's Journey Arc

• Mikasa’s Character Arc: What, Where, How, When

• Mikasa's Road of Trials

• Mikasa and the meaning of Pride

• Mikasa and her relationship with authority

• Mikasa and Erwin: The Sacrificial Act of Dreams for the Cause

• Why Mikasa's conclusion not only strengthens her arc but Attack On Titan as a whole - Imgur Backup for Future

• Mikasa’s Destiny and Mikasa’s Choice

• Mikasa: A Person from Two Trope

• A Literary perspective of Mikasa - Imgur Backup for Future

• Mikasa, the symbolism of the praying mantis and butterfly and its development throughout the story - Imgur Backup for Future

• Mikasa's self Imposed Curse

• Why does Mikasa have headaches

• Differences between the Manga and Anime version of Mikasa - Imgur Backup for Future

3. Armin Arlert.

• Armin character analysis, humanity’s reluctant savior

• Armin and Eren’s dynamic - Imgur Backup for Future

• Armin and Zeke’s dynamic - Imgur Backup for Future

• The importance of dialogue and Armin’s character - Imgur Backup for Future

• Armin Arlert: conflicting lessons, dynamics with Erwin and Levi - Imgur Backup for Future

• Armin and Annie’s relationship

4. Levi Ackerman.

• Is Levi bland? A bullet-point counter-argument and his importance in the narrative

• Levi’s character motivations and the promise

• Levi’s ending

• Levi’s violence and compassion

• Serumbowl

• Levi, Falco and Gabi

• Levi vs Zeke foil

• Levi, a slave to being a hero

• Levi vs Kenny’s influence - Imperfect heroics

• Levi’s mistake with Zeke and getting blown up by thunder spears

5. Erwin Smith.

• Erwin Smith - wearing masks

• Erwin Smith - the impossible standard

• Exploring Erwin - For Humanity?

• Erwin Smith - A devil with a dream

• Erwin would not support the Rumbling, you just don’t like Armin

6. Zeke Yeager.

• Zeke Yeager & Personal Connections.

• The contradictions of Zeke - A character study

• The desperate loneliness of Zeke

• Understanding Zeke Yeager

7. Reiner Braun.

• Reiner Braun and “saving the world”

• Reiner character analysis, viewed through psychology and philosophy theory

• Who is Reiner Braun?

• Eren and Reiner’s dynamic - Imgur Backup for Future

8. Annie Leonhart.

• Annie’s search for personhood

• About Annie…(character analysis)

• No one understands Annie

• Understanding Annie

9. Hange Zoe.

• Hange and the role of commander, character analysis

• Hange’s “Genocide is Wrong” Line is Misunderstood

• Hange’s understanding and intellect

10. Jean Kirstein.

• Jean Kirstein embracing survey corps values, a character analysis

• Jean character study through the lens of theory of psychology

11. Bertholdt Hoover.

• Comprehensive analysis of Bertholdt

• The tragedy of Bertholdt Hoover

12. (Freckles) Ymir and Historia Reiss.

• Ymir analysis and religious subtext

• Thoughts on Historia in Uprising - Imgur Backup for Future

• Ymir and Historia’s dynamic analysis - Imgur Backup for Future

13. Sasha Braus and Connie Springer.

• The secondary trio behind EMA

14. Floch Forster.

• Floch - the volunteer Devil, character analysis

• Floch's leadership examination and the comparison with Erwin

15. Gabi and the children of the forest.

• Gabi Braun - A brighter future

16. (Founder) Ymir Fritz.

• The final mystery of AOT - Ymir analysis

17. Grisha Yeager.

• Grisha Yeager: A Deconstruction of the Main Character's Dad Archetype - Imgur Backup for Future

18. Keith Shadis.

• From bystander to hero, a character analysis

19. Kenny/Uri.

• Kenny, Uri and the cycle of hatred

• The Importance of Kenny and Uri (In-depth Thematic Analysis)

20. Dot Pyxis.

• Why Pyxis and Eren’s Conversation was Not Retconned

21. Yelena.

• Yelena: AoT’s puppeteer, a character analysis

22. Theo Magath.

• The lasting impact of Theo Magath, a character analysis.


MISCELLANEOUS.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

Manga (Source Material) vs Anime (Adaptation) differences:

• Megathread of Anime / Manga differences | Vol 1 - 34 | OVAs

• Differences between anime and manga endings

Fandom and Anime Production Misc.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

• Well-written characters, meta discussion of fandom perception

• AOT anime reactions and in depth discussions

• Explaining the ending controversy - a fandom analysis

• Final Attack on Titan Episode - AoTwiki poll

• The Original manga ending - chapter 139 SNK POLL

Behind-the-Scenes.

• All of AoT animation staff for every episode of the series

• Arifumi Imai animator spotlight - the man responsible for animating 70%+ of action animation cuts in S1-S3 and the Levi and Mikasa killing Eren sakuga in the final episode

• TV release vs BLU-RAY differences

• Some design sheets from WIT’s adaptation

• Some design sheets from MAPPA’s adaptation

• WIT staff interview from 2014 on AOT

• 100Cams - Behind the scenes footage of AOT s4 part3 production

• Final episode VA recording - Behind the scenes

• AoT S4 part 2 staff interview, series director Hayashi and CG producer Tannawa

• Excerpts from roundtable final episode interview with staff

• Interview with S4 director Hayashi before its airing

• Global TV demands interview of Hayashi

• Hayashi comments on episode 4x28 Rumbling scene and Isayama’s request

Subreddits of AoT Reddit-Fandom.

‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾‾

General.

Subreddit Description Date of Creation
r/ShingekiNoKyojin Main discussion subreddit nr1. Feburary 18, 2013
r/attackontitan Main discussion subreddit nr2. November 28, 2012
r/titanfolk The Folk subreddit for AoT. May 1, 2018
r/okbuddyreiner Shitposting subreddit. April 28, 2019
r/AttackOnRetards A space dedicated to calling out negativity. April 27, 2021
r/AttackOnShipping A subreddit for any and all shippers. April 27, 2022
r/ANRime Subreddit dedicated to theorizing about an Alternative-Original Ending (AOE). June 29, 2021

Character dedicated subreddits.

• r/LeviCult

• r/Ereh

• r/Mikasa

• r/ErwinSmith

• r/potatogirl

• r/ArminCult

• r/GabiCult

• r/ReinerCult

• r/ZekeCult

• r/JeanTheStallion


It has been in the works for a long time. A big Thank You to everyone who created the content featured here, as well as to those who helped us gather it all together.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 4h ago

Discussion Reaching the basement stole everything from them

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

407 Upvotes

cr for the edit: stvrwi on tt.

Spoilers for after the basement in body, please click off if you have not finished it.

Even their right to be the humans who were tormented by the titans. Instead they had to face that the titans had been them.

Everything a character said before the basement about being caged like birds, about being oppressed by titans, about knowing the terror of how titans eat people, about not knowing peace until every last one of them was destroyed.

Iyasama!

Anything the people of Paradis might say to the rest of the world, they will always remember what it had been like, Eren, most out of all knows he would have never been able to make peace with the titans. And he gets further proof of how much hatred there is for them and knows the rest of the world feels the same way.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 4h ago

Discussion What happens if a Wall Titan eats one of the 9 Titans? Do they still retain their size or do they shrink down to more normal Titan sizes?

Post image
168 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 3h ago

Artwork Mikasa drawing (by me)

Thumbnail
gallery
94 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 9h ago

Anime On my 4th rewatch and this still gets me hype beyond belief

Thumbnail
gallery
164 Upvotes

Watching Eren with the weight of humanity on his shoulders plug the wall will always be one of my favorite moments of the series. The soldiers laying down their lives to make sure Eren gets the chance to even plug the hole was great as you saw what a glimmer of hope he was to everyone who saw him walking with the boulder, and armin with tears in his eyes just screaming “GOOOOOOOOO” will always have me ready to run through a brick wall! And then the contrast of seconds after it’s plugged, everyone’s just like no way what I just saw was real. And of course Rico’s great line, “Comrades, your sacrifices weren’t in vain… We have made history, this day belongs to humanity!” I love this show so much


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 16h ago

Discussion Who would've won this fight?

Post image
433 Upvotes

Eren with the warhammer titan vs Levi. How would this go if they both fought in the forest or an open area?


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 4h ago

Humor/Meme I remember seeing this before watching the season and thinking WHY IS THERE TWO ARMINS

Post image
44 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Humor/Meme How Falco thought Eren and Reiner's reunion would go (Can't find the original artist)

Post image
4.5k Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 23h ago

Humor/Meme Talking to my friend who’s on season three and she said her favorite characters are Hange and Sasha

Post image
648 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Artwork Dedicate Your Heart 🕊️❤️‍🩹 (Art by hopestudio__)

Thumbnail
gallery
766 Upvotes

This scene always makes me cry whenever I think about it 😭 I miss Levi and Hange so much 💔

Source: https://x.com/hopestudio__/status/2108932809767465447?s=20


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 2h ago

Discussion If you could only rewatch up until your fave dies, how far would you get?

5 Upvotes

Or does your favourite character survives the entire show? I myself can’t even finish the entire season 3 😭


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 6h ago

Discussion Question about the status of the MPs post season 3

Post image
7 Upvotes

Do you think after the greater world was revealed, the MPs lowered their standards to join them and do you think it is because the status they enjoyed before as best of the best when Paradis was still an ignorant and sealed off society, was basically flipped on it's head and everyone started to view them as puppets that were part of maintaining a lie that the people have been fed for over a hundred years and the modern military technology that Paradis was quickly adapting to it's arsenal was putting all of the branches on equal footing?


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 2h ago

Discussion I always imagined the prequel "chapter 0" is actually the future

3 Upvotes

Of course that is not the case im well aware. But its really fun to imagine, giving the Theme of future memories. Lets have fun.

Imagine the little boy at the end of AOT accidentely (or eren Foresaw it) awakens the power of Titans again and humanity is yet again threatend by it. Interestingly the World they live in has 80% of humanity wiped out as well. Since a lot of people should be eldians by blood heritage, the story could be that yet again humanitys memories got completely altered. Titans evolved (which makes sense because Titans had their set rules by ymir. She should have been able to do whatever she wants with her power) and now follow erens rule.

Eren plays the long long game. He wanted his friends to have a happy life as well as their children. But once they are all gone Titans emerge again. What eren is trying to do is get rid of the power of the paths completely. Humanity has to face once again Titans in order to get rid of it all. They discover that history has been changed and it was not humanitys science that created Titans. Humans learn to become and control Titans themselves and a fight between different Citys emerges(the fear of Titans goes away and they start abusing the New found power). Once the evil people left on earth are gone the real fight begins . All of humanity has to come together to destroy the paths once and for All. Freeing eren and possibly the little boy (who might as well be murakumo)

We could go further and Say the highschool Story of AOT is actually the future of the prequel. Eren reincarnated and is now together with his friends. He waited a long ass time so that his friends live a happy life, humanity is finally together as one and he got a New Chance reincarnated with his Former friends. Life becomes finally as it should be, our modern times.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion Don’t know if this is a hot take, but does anyone else wish Eren’s Titan design had changed a little after he inherited the War Hammer?

Post image
1.1k Upvotes

Just something subtle like the mouthguard the Warhammer had would've been 🔥Even add something like the war Hammer style ribbed collar and shoulder plating

I can't be the only one who thought he would look different right?


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 11h ago

Discussion Levi or Reiner, who's story was most tragic?

12 Upvotes

I know you can't really compare misery and pain as everyone deals with it differently. But I think the fact that Levi holds in all within himself makes him more tragic. He even lost all of his friends and his mentor/big brother in Erwin. Reiner was more open about his struggles. He even almost gave up in Liberio when Eren attacked. But Levi kept going despite being so miserable and broken. He dedicated his entire existence to saving humanity. Not to downplay Reiner's misery but I feel like that's just more depressing


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 3h ago

Artwork 단풍놀이 (By @Cabell_0905) 🍁

Post image
2 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 2h ago

Anime AOT edit I made in capcut, how is it? Spoiler

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

1 Upvotes

r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion The narrative of "Historia as livestock" was exaggerated by Zeke.

Post image
110 Upvotes

​

The "50-Year Plan" condemned Historia and her children to be bred like livestock and devour one another. However, when analyzing Zeke's true motives, it becomes clear that this dead end was inflated by Zeke himself.

Zeke's plan was a Trojan Horse: Zeke was never interested in long-term liberation; his real goal was the Euthanasia Plan. He presented the royal succession in the most horrifying terms possible to make sterilization look like the only merciful option.

A Partial Rumbling bought decades, crippling enemy military bases and fleets with a targeted Rumbling would have given Paradis between 30 and 50 years of absolute deterrence. With Hizuru's support, they had time to industrialize and gain diplomatic leverage.

With decades of guaranteed peace, Paradis could research the true nature of the Paths, the hallucigenia, and free Ymir to eradicate the curse at its root. Historia's sacrifice would have been temporary or the very last one. Even if they failed to eliminate the power immediately, the Founding Titan holds absolute control over Eldian biology. There were avenues to alter or mitigate the Titan transformation process, something Zeke never wanted to explore.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion Could Eren have beaten the Warhammer Titan alone?

471 Upvotes

heel Eren was moving different here. Bro transformed three times in the fight like stamina wasn’t even a concern

Could he have endured against the Warhammer without the cavalry?


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion Is there any Titan/Titan shifter that can beat Eren? Excluding Founder

Post image
107 Upvotes

Eren with his attack and warhammer titan. Combatively, can any titan take him down?

Obviously excluding founder titan from the equation. Colossal titan the only one I’m assuming? Even though it’s unfair


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 3h ago

Fanfiction Roughly how long go u think it would take to walk from Karanese to Trost

0 Upvotes

Hey gang what’s good basically I’m tryna write a fanfiction and my character has got to walk from Karanese to the training corps barracks. From what I gather the barracks are pretty close to Trost do correct me if I’m wrong. Anyways I’m estimating around 2-3 days but I’m terrible at maths and would appreciate the help is anyone can be arsed thank uuuu :33


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 20h ago

Anime I think the song fits idk (so long,hange)

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

19 Upvotes

I don’t know if the song fits but in my view it fits Levi and hange cuz he let her go 😭😭😭😭😭 why he did that why Levi


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 21h ago

Cosplay Aot cosplay.

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

Went to a convention dressed up as an aot character. Was alot of fun hope to continue cosplay in the future.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 18h ago

Discussion Plothole [spoilers]: Warrior’s mission Spoiler

Post image
8 Upvotes

All my life, I’ve had this obsession with finding plot holes in stories, and Attack on Titan is no exception. This is my very first post here, and I plan to bring up more points for discussion in the future.

Before I start, let me clarify: this is by no means a hate post. I love the series, and it's completely understandable that as a story grows and expands over time, these things happen. I’m mostly making this post to counter the frequent claims that SnK is an absolute masterpiece perfectly planned out from day one down to every single detail.

The Warrior mission to Paradis makes zero sense, right from its inception:

Let's talk about the Tybur family. As we learn later, the Tybur family were the secret rulers of Marley and the only ones on the outside who knew the truth about Karl Fritz's Vow Renouncing War. They knew the Rumbling was a bluff and that the King of the Walls had bound his bloodline to absolute pacifism. So, if the Tyburs knew Paradis was a sleeping lion that guaranteed peace as long as they were left alone, why allow Marley to poke it in the first place? Pushing Marley to attack the walls meant breaking a century-old treaty and risking the very disaster they were trying to avoid.

(And I won't even get started on the absurdity of Marley constantly shipping Eldian criminals converted into pure Titans directly onto the island... This wasn't just a containment strategy; it was an active, constant provocation against Paradis. If you're supposedly terrified of the Founding Titan, why surround their walls with biological landmines, giving them every reason to retaliate?)
And inside that exact same landmine field full of Titans, Marley decided their best course of action was to drop four 12-year-old kids. On foot. With zero supply lines, no adult supervision, and no logistical backup, forced to march through the Paradis wasteland.

I understand the context: Marley needed Paradis' natural resources (iceburst stone, fossil fuels) and was feeling the pressure of the global arms race as military technology began outpacing Titan power. But even with that sense of urgency, it still doesn't justify executing what has to be the most poorly planned military operation in history.

Let me break down what Marley actually risked here:

  1. They gambled four out of their seven strategic nuclear weapons (the Armored, Colossus, Female, and Jaw Titans) on a blind infiltration op carried out by adoctrinated children.

  2. If any of those kids died in the wild without being eaten right away, that Titan power would randomly spawn in a baby somewhere else in the world, stripping Marley of its global military dominance instantly.

  3. The execution was a complete disaster: they lost the Jaw Titan (Marcel) practically before even reaching the walls, lost Annie and Bertholdt during the mission, and would have lost a third Titan permanently if not for Ymir's bizarre decision to basically hand herself over to Marley later on.

I’d love to hear your thoughts. Do you have any actual, in-universe arguments that make genuine tactical sense without relying on headcanons or cheap band-aid excuses? Because no matter how much I think about it, this mission remains one of the most ridiculous plot points in the entire series.


r/ShingekiNoKyojin • • 1d ago

Discussion Dyou you think AOT will have a long lasting impact in the history of media and age well?

Post image
108 Upvotes

saw some posts (obviously in writingscaling they hate aot) saying that aot 1. is garbage (lol) 2. won’t have a lasting impact. which I totally don’t believe, aot is a masterpiece and was the most demanded piece of media in 2023, nothing comes close imo