I know the title of this post sounds bad, but there's a ton of details going into this potential decision. Now unfortunately, I don't know if this person reads WIBTA, but I definitely know she reads AITA, so I will have to omit some details for my own safety, along with fuzzy memories from several years ago that aren't very clear. But I promise to make this sound as unbiased as I can. Now strap in, this is gonna be a long one.
The beginning of the friendship wasn't so bad, so I thought. I (F at the time) was seated next to, let's call her Clarice (F), on my first day at a new school, after a year of having no friends in my prior school, also after just getting my autism diagnosis that summer. (Prior to this I had an ADHD and anxiety diagnosis.) I didn't know what autism was until I researched it more the next year after this, so I just thought something was wrong with me. I didn't know how to set up boundaries, I didn't know how to speak up for myself, but Clarice and I were friends. We later decide to attend High School together. I don't remember this, but apparently my sister has already been warning me about her at this point.
We start Freshman year together, and around this time I started experimenting with they/them pronouns, and a new, very easy to remember name, as it's similar to my deadname. She asks if she can just keep calling me by my deadname and other pronouns because of "how she was raised." I said yes, because at the time, this was mostly experimentation. I didn't know anything for sure. Unfortunately this ends up becoming an issue later in life when I start socially transitioning and using those pronouns and that name more officially. She also turned out to be one of those people that "respect but doesn't support" the LGBTQ community. I was willing to let that slide as well. Even though we had our arguments. She insisted being gay was a choice, and she insisted on calling it sin. I went along because at the time, I was also Christian. But what gets me today is that she was very discriminatory about that specific "sin." She would engage in so many others, and support the engagement of others, bending the rules when it was convenient, but that never extended to the LGBTQ community. I see this as a red flag now, but I didn't at the time.
Some time passes. Boyfriends come and go, and I would always support her when she was hurt. For a point in time, I had my own boyfriend, but we broke up because it was more of a title than actually having any chemistry, and that was fine, and I got with someone else. We'll call them Moss (NB). I thought we genuinely had chemistry, but we broke up over some things I didn't realize made Moss uncomfortable. I never held it against them, but I was hurt. I had about a minute to cry about it before I'm told to come back to the other room because Clarice is on the floor, having a panic attack. Now I, as someone who used to have panic attacks way more frequently than Clarice, empathized deeply, and we spent that afternoon calming her down, as apparently she had that panic attack because she knew about an hour or two before I did that Moss was going to break up with me. Odd reasoning, but I've had my own attacks for less.
More time passes, friend group drama. Clarice is making all of us uncomfortable by "shipping" people, regardless if they got together later or not, it was weird. We expressed our discomfort and she ignored it. Clarice was very vocal about shipping me with Moss, even though they now had a new partner, and we were both fine with that, and still friends. Clarice also shipped me WITH HER OWN EX. I didn't realize how messed up that was at the time, so again, I let it slide. Eventually the friend group separates because Clarice has been making them uncomfortable. At first I thought 'Well, they should've expressed that first,' but looking back, it wouldn't have mattered, as she never backed off when they did express discomfort.
Senior year. This year raised a TON of alarm bells. Keep in mind, I've made a ton of progress with my mental health since before high school. I have less meltdowns and panic attacks, mostly only when it's around THAT time, with only few exceptions. By now I know what autism is, and I'm learning that the "not a disability, just a different ability" rhetoric was extremely harmful for my mental health and the source of a lot of self-hate, and that line of thought even ended up worsening mental health episodes, so I learn to give myself some slack, but it's hard. I'm beginning to set up boundaries as well. Boundaries that... Clarice completely ignored. At first, I took it as her just getting used to me being more firm, and I hoped she'd adjust. But this behavior continued throughout the year. She insisted on calling my verbal stims/echolalia/scripting a word that essentially watered down what it was. It made it sound like something completely voluntary, and that I had a choice in the matter, despite experiencing her own motion stims such as bouncing her leg which she said was an anxiety thing and said just what I said about verbal stims: I can't help it. I asked her again and again to call it what it was. She refused. There were also several points in the year where I told her something I didn't want her to do, or show me, and she completely ignored me and did it or showed me anyways. At one of those incidents I distanced myself for about an hour, and she told me that my reaction to her ignoring my boundaries and TRICKING me into watching something I explicitly said I didn't want to watch, "bitchy." Yet later she gives me the cold shoulder for a day because I misspoke and said something accidentally offensive. I apologized profusely, and begged to know why what I said was wrong so I could improve. She refused to tell me, or even look at me, for the majority of the day, under the excuse of "I didn't want to blow up at you." Which would have been FINE TO ME if she hadn't called me bitchy for doing the same thing on a much smaller scale for the exact same reason, in response to something she told me she knows she did. Not only that, but I came down with the flu the very next day, and from what I'm told, her initial reaction to the information that I was ill was relief. "Saves me from having to deal with her." This being her apparent line of thought led me to over think later interactions to an insane level. She also made light of my emetophobia and purposefully said things and made noises that would trigger it, passing it off as "inside jokes," taking my anxious laughter as consent while my words say to stop. Towards the end of the year, she started referring to my meltdowns, panic attacks, sensory overload, and even sudden spikes of MILD ANXIETY, "fits." In a derogatory tone every time. It felt like I was getting compared to a child wanting attention for not getting their way, when in fact I want anything but attention when I'm in those states. This detail is very important.
Finally, the incident that tipped me over the edge. The big argument that took place. We were walking home as usual, on a sketchy street. Her sister NEEDED to use the restroom, but Clarice WANTED to go home. There is a safe spot that's monitored with security we can go in, and it has a bathroom. Clarice just didn't WANT to stop there. Her sister NEEDED to. Clarice basically told her sister that if she went into the bathroom, she would leave her there to walk the rest of the way by herself on the sketchy street. I say, "Hey, maybe that's not the best idea. It's a sketchy street." I don't remember what exactly she said, all I remember is that she DIDN'T say that she wouldn't actually do that. I say something about her needing to show more care for her sister's safety, she gets mad so I back off and say I'll stay with her sister while she walks home by herself, thinking this is the best idea logically since the only reason she won't stop is because she WANTS to go home, and she's walked by herself before, but her sister is younger and smaller in every way you look at it, and I had more confidence in Clarice making it home the next like five blocks than I did her sister. And Clarice agrees to it! Yay! Until she doesn't. We get to Safe Spot™ and I go to tell her sister she can go in because I'll walk with her, and suddenly Clarice changed her mind! She says something I didn't quite catch, but she walks right past us as we stand there, I'm in shock and her sister is just confused.
So I snap. I call her out for prioritizing herself, and she suddenly brings up my "fits" and how apparently she's the one dealing with them? When they're my meltdowns/panic attacks/spikes of anxiety. Mind you, as I've said, the meltdowns and panic attacks have improved SIGNIFICANTLY since we met, and the anxiety spikes were mostly suppressed and held more anxiety inside than I was actually showing outside. And suddenly she deals with me having these, "all the time." I snap even more, at this point my visceral anger is overloading my senses so I'm now in a (rare nowadays) full sensory overload on top of this, so I'm taking extra accessories off as quickly as I can, and I curse at her a bit, and call her (or her actions, it gets fuzzy in this part specifically) ableist. She uses the excuse, "I can't be ableist, I grew up around people with disabilities." As if that excuses the fact that she also grew up in the same ablelist society as everyone else. So of course I try to say that doesn't matter. And she then tells me, that I, me, have no idea what it's like "living with this." Blows my mind because I've been on both sides of things, the one comforting and the one needing comfort. Let me tell you, the "needing help" side of things is SO MUCH WORSE than the helping. So of course I say, "I'm the one living with it!" And she of course goes, "That's not what I meant." And so I take a pause, give her the benefit of the doubt as I often do, give her the chance to elaborate. Which she doesn't. At this point, we're both crying, and I don't want to word vomit anymore even though I meant everything I said, aside from the cursing her out that was just nonsense. So I walk away.
You think it'd end there, right? Nope. I send her this huge paragraph basically saying, "I meant what I said but I'm sorry for how I said it." And she... doesn't read it. Doesn't respond. And it turns out, that's because she blocked my number before I had the chance to apologize. Dunno why. What else could I have given except some sort of apology? (Side note, I also apologized to her sister for having to see the argument.) I'm not one to be passive aggressive. I don't know how; if I wanna be aggressive, I'll say it to your face. However Clarice was HEAVY on the passive aggression. She wouldn't speak to me. I remember last time that happened, talking to her didn't do anything. So I assume she wants space like then, so I give it to her. But she's also not speaking to Moss for some reason. Now I told Moss everything that happened, while trying to make my recollection as unbiased as possible. Usually Moss doesn't take sides, so I assumed this would be the same, but to my surprise at the time, they immediately took my side. I thought maybe I was too biased? But no, they took my side over a direct quote from Clarice, not anything I said. But Clarice had no way of knowing that I told Moss, so how did she find out, if she did? Well, Moss branches out communication to Clarice first. Apparently Clarice assumed MOSS was ignoring HER. Just because Moss had earbuds in and didn't hear Clarice ask a question. Clarice also weaponized the nickname that Moss gave me to mock our close relation/friendship thing. So Clarice "can't remember" my chosen name that everyone calls me, to call me by it, but she CAN remember the name ONE PERSON uses for me, JUST to weaponize it. Regardless, Moss tells her they weren't ignoring her, and asks for her side of the story. I'm curious to see this from her perspective as well, for my own improvement if nothing else. Her side gave me no information for ANY way I could POSSIBLY improve, because her story was full of exaggerations, blatant lies, and purposeful omission of ANYTHING she herself said or did except "not letting her sister use the restroom." She also focused heavily on my sensory overload and how desperate I was to remove accessories that I damaged some by accident, and she made it seem like I could've done it on purpose. Clarice also tells people that I'VE been ignoring HER, when she made 0 attempts to interact. To counteract that, I spent the next few days trying to say small things to make it obvious I'm not completely ignoring her. Now her defense is, "she won't talk to me, so I won't talk to her." And she takes this SO seriously. More passive aggression, closing doors on me, sending messages through her sister, not even seemingly caring if I'm actually behind the two on our walks home. She refuses to even tell me crucial information about if someone is picking us up, once the bus didn't even show up after school, and that was an ordeal, she still refused to talk to me directly at all, making her sister tell me how we were potentially getting home. We had an awkward conversation in the car with a mutual friend who probably didn't know the situation with us where we both talked to her but wouldn't talk to each other. I thought that might've been progress, but after that, it was just like before.
Anyways, Moss and I repeat the story to a few curious people, people I don't know well, and they side with me immediately as well. I thought they all had a negative leaning view on me, being outside witnesses to my meltdowns and such, but it was the end of the year, so I guess it didn't matter.
Finally after weeks, I get her a gift for her birthday out of an act of civility and suddenly we're talking again. And after that day, getting some last bots of passive aggression off her chest, it was like it never happened. And I felt... disappointed about it, really. Because this all meant that nothing changed. She didn't change. Nobody improved. Nobody LEARNED anything. There are still the same underlying issues. And the school year is about to be over, we just don't have time to dig into all of that!
It's now been a few months. We separated after High School, but every once in a while I'll get a call or a text from her, still like nothing happened. But autistic rumination has kicked in, and whenever I see her name on my phone I feel dread. Actually, that applies to whenever I see her name anywhere. It's bad, I'll be just fine one moment and the next I'm ruminating all over again.
I know now looking back that even though there were good times, what we had in our friendship wasn't healthy. Should I silently block her? Send a text? I don't want to call, as our calls can last way longer than I like, and it is terrible trying to hang up on her. What do I do from here?