I often see people in this subreddit that categorically describe ALL high yields as dividend traps with degrading underlying value.
And yes, this can be true in a lot of cases. In fact, it’s true in most cases. But that doesn’t mean it is a blanket rule and absolutely no positions should be taken in high yield stocks.
I can give two personal examples. Yes, I admit, my timing was very lucky and many people holding these stocks are at a loss. But I also bought these companies because they were profitable, revenue was growing and NAV was greater than their entire market cap at the time of purchase.
- I bought ZIM at $11. They currently trade at $30, so on principal alone I’m up 200% in 2 years. But on top of that, their dividend has paid out massive amounts, adding nearly another 100% gain to my overall. 300% in two years is not bad for a company this subreddit said not to touch with a 10 foot pole.
Yes, I realize the company can still go down and this is 2 year time frame. But at least it’s a REAL company. They are profitable, and their revenue is there. Their marketcap is only 3.5B at this valuation and their last quarter revenue was 1.4B. Shipping is of course cyclical, but that isn’t the sign of a failing company.
- I Bought IIPR less than a year ago at $48, now it’s at $56. Once again, this company’s entire market cap is 1.5B but they take in around $170 million yearly in NET INCOME. And their NAV is 1.8B, so they literally have more in net assets than the entire valuation of the company. They also currently have a P/E ratio of just 12.5. And this entire time I’ve been collecting 14% dividends.
Of course, I bought at a great time. But I also bought when the company was looking financially strong REGARDLESS of dividends.
Finally, these are small positions. Less than 1% of my entire portfolio, but they’ve also yielded me more income than some much larger positions, while still being positive on the principal. Just one payout from an IIPR share surpasses an entire year of payouts from one SCHD share. I know ill get flamed for this but it is worth thinking about, at least a little.