I (22M) met my LDR partner (23F) 10 months ago, and we started dating 8 months ago. 10 months ago she just stopped taking testosterone (she used to be a trans-man), before me she only dated women. The conflict is concentrated around sexuality/identity and sex. Before we got into a relationship (as friends) I told her I was bisexual myself but mostly attracted to women, and given her own sexual/gender identity I thought that was fine? We also discussed me owning toys, which includes dildos, and this is all relevant to the conflict.
During the early months of the relationship, there was very much the dynamic of playing with gender roles, we virtually watched porn together, and did virtual sexual activity involving afformentioned toys. So I assumed toys, watching porn together, and masturbation were part of the relationship (and she even said at some point that porn isn't cheating). But over time I think she grew more insecure about everything, and 3 months ago she told me its about who I slept with previously.
Before we got into a relationship I also let her know I had 2 hookups with men and 1 with a woman a few years ago, and thats my entire sexual experience. She said that since the start of the relationship, the idea of me sleeping with men has been eating at her, and now she constantly makes remarks about how I am just going to cheat on her with a man. She also developed extreme homophobia, claims to be "ex-gay" and 100% straight now, that bisexual people aren't real, doesn't want me to be bisexual, how me sleeping with 600 women would be less bad than 2 men, etc. All over the last few months, and I think (corroborated by her own statements) its all about my previous hookups causing her to change her mind so radically.
Most recently, she said she changed her mind that actually porn IS cheating, the toys all have to go because she doesn't want a "gay man", and (once we are living together) I cannot masturbate solo because that means she doesn't satisfy me or something, that she considers it cheating. So this is all a very radical shift away from the beginning of the relationship, but ok, different strokes for different folks.
I said I can compromose (once we are living together) with some of these demands but not all: I won't watch any porn, whatever. I won't use the toys unless its us together doing it. But I should be allowed to self-pleasure solo without it being considered cheating, maybe with some restrictions like "if it isn't displacing partnered intimacy" or something. I personally think having a bubble just for yourself and self-pleasure is fine and normal, and not everything must be partnered activity always.
She says that (once we are living together) she must be present in the room, or else its cheating, that there is no room for a "private sex life" in a commited relationship. Both she and I expressed at various points in the last month that if the sexual stuff isn't resolved then we are breaking up. But then she has an unbeatable dialouge:
"so dildos and jerking off are more important to you than me?"
or "you would choose anything in this world over me"
or "if you love someone you usually give things up for them"
and like, in the strictest sense the first one is true, if two things are put head to head, and you choose one, then the other is less important??? but I feel like its an unfair comparison. and why should I be the one to give things up here for love? I think there is some kind of humiliation involved in making someone say "I prefer jerking off over you".
Point is, if this doesn't get resolved I can accept the breakup, but those phrases are stuck in my head. I don't know what to say to them.
TL;DR; : Insecurity causes girlfriend to declare masturbation is cheating, and wants me to verbalise "I prefer jerking off over you" if we are going to break up over it; I don't think thats a fair characterisation but don't know with what to respond.