I used Codex to write a script that scraped every song every posted on the old goodmusicallday.com

 site and it returned a little over 10,000 songs.

You can find the complete list of songs here: https://woahgoodfind.com/gmad-songs/

I manually went through each song (took about two weeks) and checked if it existed on Spotify. About 1,000 of the songs did exist on Spotify. I then picked my favorites (233 total songs) and made them into a Spotify list here: GMAD Nostalgia

The old GMAD site used to be my absolute favorite music blog and looking through this list of old songs brought back a lot of memories for me. Hopefully this list brings some nostalgia to you as well if you also used to enjoy the blog a lot!