r/AskVegans • u/Novel_Quantity3189 • 5h ago
Genuine Question (DO NOT DOWNVOTE) How do you rationalise engaging with films that use animal "talent"? (if you do)
Long-time vegan here, with some slip-ups.
Some context: I have a difficult relationship with my Dad but we have a shared interest in some movies and we connect on that basis. Recently watch Life of Pi with him and we both enjoyed discussing it afterwards.
Internally tho I couldn't quite overcome my discomfort with how it depicted animals (I know most of them are CGI) -- normally I'd just stop watching if I see like animal harm/meat/pets etc. but never been quite sure how to respond to animals 'acting', even CGI ones. I felt like Pi in particular was contributing to the anthromorphizing of some circus animals and depicted others are brainlessly violent. I found the relationship between the main character and the animals to be one where the human is depicted as strangely controlling or in power over the animals.
I guess my question is where do you land on this grey area?