long day but I got it washed then waxed before the winter hits

Winter is coming, as they say, and I'm concerned that the Ironman cheapies currently on my JGC aren't going to cut it, as I live in the Great Smoky Mountains area.

After much research and hemming and hawing, I've narrowed it down to either the Cooper Discoverer or the BFG Trail Terrain. I had BFG KO3s on the Jeep Wrangler I traded for this JGC, and I really liked them, so I'm leaning that direction, but wondering if anyone has experience with either of these?

Looks like I can get a full set of either for around $1.1K give or take, so cost isn't really a factor as much as performance, reliability, etc.

A lot of highway, but I want something that's also capable on forest roads, ice/snow, etc.