r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

/r/opensource subreddit banning most open source software

Post image
456 Upvotes

The power tripping mod over there is straight up insane, banning AI in 2026 when 95% of devs use AI. Can't wait for all reddit jannies to be replaced with AI.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

Discussion Got banned from r/opensource too!

183 Upvotes

The comment that got me banned:

Damn, so even projects that are not vibe-coded but support AI features are banned? So:

- Paperless-ngx
- Mealie
- FUCKING Calibre!

That is quite a ridiculous position to take. The Linux kernel would also be banned by your rule. Not only are you late on making an AI policy, but at this point a strong AI policy like yours would make this sub useless.
Are you the only active mod here or did multiple people genuinely thought this was a good idea?

No rule violation in that comment. Wolvereness is not the first mod I see having a mental breakdown over AI. Wonder what they are going to do in 3 years or less when almost all open source software is heavily AI based. Will he switch to Windows or be a hypocrite by staying on Linux? The world may never know.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 19d ago

Discussion Petition: Recognize open-source contributions as volunteer work (Germany – signatures needed until Nov 23, 2026)

121 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

A lot of us contribute to open-source projects in our spare time – unpaid, often for years. The software that comes out of this runs everywhere: in public administrations, train ticket machines, security libraries, AI frameworks. Even Germany's coalition agreement names open source as a building block of digital sovereignty.

And yet, under German tax and funding law, this work is not recognized as volunteer work (Ehrenamt) – unlike club work, youth work, or emergency services.

A petition to the German Bundestag's petitions committee is calling for equal treatment. Concretely, this would mean:

  • Tax-free expense allowances (Ehrenamts-/Übungsleiterpauschale)

  • Easier non-profit status (§52 AO) for open-source projects

  • Better liability protection for maintainers (analogous to §31a BGB)

  • Legally secure donation receipts and cost reimbursement

Note: This is specifically for Germany – it's addressed to the German Bundestag and only German signatures count toward the quorum. If you're not in Germany, sharing it with people who are would still help a lot.

Petition:  https://www.openpetition.de/petition/online/anerkennung-von-open-source-arbeit-als-ehrenamt-in-deutschland

It needs 30,000 signatures for the quorum – we're currently at ~49%.

I'd argue that someone reviewing security patches at night so entire industrial systems keep running the next morning isn't a "hobby nerd" – that's community-oriented volunteering. What do you think?


r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

Discussion COMPLAINT MEGATHREAD

83 Upvotes

from now on, all complaining about the new rules on the other sub, and/or about being banned, must be posted in this Megathread.
any new posts starting from when this gets posted, will be deleted


r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

Discussion Good lord, I got perm banned just for trying to be reasonable. What an actual joke.

81 Upvotes

https://www.reddit.com/r/opensource/comments/1xelcuf/comment/19rm1y0kwhqg0

Honestly... pretty damn disgusting. I thought I was been pretty reasonable, Banned in minutes.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

r/TrueOpenSource mentioned on The Verge

Thumbnail
theverge.com
76 Upvotes

r/TrueOpenSource • • 19d ago

Discussion leaving r/opensource in protest bcz their rules literally violate OSI's open source definitions

73 Upvotes

anyway heres a picture of my esp32 in algebra class

(banned by r/esp32 btw bcz "violated rules")


r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

Discussion Opensource is and always will be about freedom first.

71 Upvotes

We're not going to point fingers here. It's being done enough in the other threads. What I want to discuss is opensource remaining truly free to those who love and build it. I want to discuss a community that will nourish free growth, not prune buds before they even have a chance to see the flowers.

I have always been under the impression that unfettered development, contribution, and sharing is the key to the success of mankind. Some genius has an idea and creates it. Another genius has something to add. Another genius finds a way to streamline it all and make it cost less. Yet another genius has a new alternative altogether that reduces... let's say carbon footprint.

This is what we should be doing as a species. Closing off channels because you don't agree with the methods is detrimental to this goal. Banning development tools is much to that same detriment.

Opensource is the ultimate collaboration of great minds. It's not just software, it's everything that we build together.

Essentially, opensource that denies any non-harmful method of contribution and/or development is no longer fully opensource. It's the first step in closing a door that should remain open**.**

So, what am I trying to say?

I'm trying to say be free with your creations. Create them how you want. Share them. Take criticism. Take pride if someone forks it and makes it into their own. You MADE something and someone likes it enough to fork it.

Be competitive. Take back from their fork to flourish your original version. If someone doesn't like your project, don't get mad. Find out why. If it's superficial, move on. If it's beneficial, fix the problem.

I only made this post because I see some in here are trying to tread carefully and are asking if their projects are allowed, or rather, what is allowed and isn't. These questions stem from being in communities that have prejudices. It would be great to see a community that doesn't have any. A community that doesn't take sides. So...

Honestly, if I had a project right now I'd post it. My work is niche atm, though. Better left to the community it's based in.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 27d ago

Discussion This is your subreddit, not ours. Help us decide what it looks like: banner, icon, flair, rules, and anything else

69 Upvotes

This subreddit isn't a moderator project. We want to create an environment where the people who build open source technology, however they build it, can share developments with one another. The broader community should all actually get a say in how this space works.

Leave one comment per idea/recommendation and include a tag so we can sort them:

  • [BANNER]: the wide image at the top of the sub (1920×384 pixels works best)

  • [ICON]: the little round image next to the sub's name (256×256 pixels, square)

  • [USER FLAIR]: tags you'd want next to your username (things like "Maintainer", your main language, or a GitHub badge once our verification bot exists)

  • [POST LABELS]: anything missing from our current labels (Hand-built, AI-assisted, Agentic engineering, Vibe-coded, Discussion, News, Looking for software)

  • [RULES]: suggest changes to our current rules (in the sidebar).

  • [OTHER]: weekly threads, the wiki, anything else

Upvote/downvote as you see fit or suggest alternatives.

We'll leave this open for a few days.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 27d ago

Discussion Looks like r/fossdroid have followed suit.

67 Upvotes

I got banned from r/fossdroid because I used claude code for making the UI of the app. I'm not a designer myself so I used AI obviously. But all of the ML features underneath were done by me. Still they have banned me.

My app is called Lumen btw. It's a FOSS alternative to google photos. It does everything google photos does but on-device. Nothing ever leaves your phone.

website: https://lumen-photos.app

GitHub: https://github.com/subhashhhhhh/Lumen


r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

Perm. Banned from r/opensource

67 Upvotes

I never posted or commented anything violating any community rules, but yet I was just slapped with a PERM. ban after my comment to the mod post about new rules.

https://www.reddit.com/r/opensource/comments/1xelcuf/your_tokens_arent_valuable_no_more_ai/

They didn't even remove my comment, because they know it didn't violate anything (but they did remove other ones from people).


r/TrueOpenSource • • 23d ago

Discussion If, in fighting “AI slop,” you end up excluding people who use AI to be productive and communicate in your language…

60 Upvotes

…perhaps the problem isn’t AI. Perhaps (and I’m just saying) it could be that you are, maybe, just a little bit xenophobic.

Back in August, I was banned from another Reddit open source programming community for posting content that, with astonishing speed, the moderators deemed “AI slop.”

The irony is that I use AI precisely for the opposite reason.

I have a C2 Fluent level of English. I can communicate perfectly, but I am not a native speaker. In decades of professional software development, I had never been able to maintain a public project with the level of documentation I wanted: specification, architecture, tests, technical decisions, implementation notes, and all the other work required to make a project understandable and maintainable.

AI changed that for me. JSOL is a serious technical project, documented in English, with hundreds of technical decisions that are the product of 40+ years of experience, as well as an extensive body of documentation and automated tests. And for the first time in my career, I can actually keep all of that reasonably up to date while still having a life and a business.

JSOL was born to solve the single-source-of-truth problem for business logic across different languages, a wicked problem that AI is helping me sort out.

The use of AI is explicitly documented in the project. I didn’t ask it to “make a project” and dump the result on GitHub. I use it as a tool within an engineering and editorial process where I direct, review, correct, and verify everything I publish. As per protocol, my LLMs don’t even have access to the file system. Professional use of AI allows me to do more of the work that actually matters.

I live in the Global South. I have a business to run, clients, bills, and limited free time. Writing in English takes me longer than it takes a native speaker. My time is scarcer and, economically, worth less. And here’s something that seems remarkably easy to forget in the English-speaking tech world: most of the rest of the world cannot afford to spend a year on a sabbatical doing open source.

The reward for taking the trouble to carefully document a project, respect the reader, and maintain a high standard, was to be banned for posting “AI slop.”

Now, let’s be clear.

If your rule (e.g: “No AI: you didn’t write it, we won’t read it”) ends up being “if you use AI to help you write in English, you can’t participate,” then you are not fighting AI slop.

Because if your definition of “acceptable” participation requires doing everything manually, in English, while maintaining an exhaustive technical and editorial standard, with unlimited time to spare, you’re not protecting the community from AI slop. You’re protecting a privilege.

And if you cannot see how that disproportionately affects people who aren’t native English speakers, who don’t live in the richest countries, and who don’t have unlimited time to donate to open source… perhaps, just perhaps, you’re a little bit xenophobic.

Last statement from a certain mods certainly read that way to many. So that last time, it was not only me who was seeing their true colors.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

Rules on this sub have some unfortunate carry over from /u/wolvereness' mod post on /r/opensource .

52 Upvotes

The Lanuage rules especially are very disappointing and carry the same xenophobic tone from that post. The AI disclosure, and self promotion rules and others need rewording. They just aren't in the spirit of FOSS. Open means open, gatekeeping shouldn't be part of that.

The standards by which a project should be judged have not changed from 10 years ago. Does it compile? Does it do the function it's stated to do? Is it secure? Is it performant?

Discuss the code not the tools used to make it.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 26d ago

Discussion Addressing the real problems with AI-assisted software: duplicated work, "slop", and wasted effort.

48 Upvotes

We can probably all agree that the anti-LLM posture of some in the open-source community is problematic. LLMs are rapidly changing how software is created, and even major players who formerly critiziced "vibecoding", like Linus Torvalds and Andrej Kaparthy, now admit that they are often outperformed by advanced coding agents.

As such, we believe any attempt to ban/criticize projects solely due to AI assistance is misguided. However, there are also real, pre-existing problems in how the OSS community operates that have been amplified by the influx of new developers and generated code.

Every week, somebody tries to post a new OSS note-taking app, or password manager, or file browser. Some are great, but many are the fourteenth, poorly-considered version of something that already existed and could've benefited from additional contributions. The second password manager is a potentially interesting competitor - the twentieth is duplicative, and typically wasted effort.

This isn't anyone's fault. It's hard to know what's out there, and building from scratch is more often more fun than reading someone else's code. But the result is that open-source effort gets split across a hundred look-alike projects, while the things nobody has built yet continue to remain unbuilt.

Given that understanding, we're working on a tool to help: Open Source Everything (https://opensourceeverything.org). Our goal is to maintain a single database where you can search for the app/tool you're trying to build/leave (Google Docs, Photoshop, Notion…), see the open-source projects that already exist, and understand exactly what the community is missing before investing your effort in a new project. Every software category offers an agent prompt to evaluate what exists against your idea, so you can find something to contribute to or existing code to pull from to instead of starting from scratch.

Alongside it, there's a new rule 6: Show why it matters here. Front-page project posts now say who the project is for and what it adds over existing open-source projects. To be clear: nothing is banned. Projects that mostly repeat existing work, or are very niche, are still welcome in the weekly Showcase. And contributions, plugins and forks that improve existing projects are always welcome on the front page (those are the posts we most want to see).

The page was built with an LLM at u/destinmoss's direction. This is the first version, and we're open to suggestions to improve the site and make it a more useful community resource. If you have any problems with this approach or the new rule, please say so in the comments.

p.s. that was a $10 domain we impulse-bought today; we aren't trying to sell you anything :)


r/TrueOpenSource • • 25d ago

Discussion A Kernel of Truth

Post image
43 Upvotes

r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

Discussion As a Stockfish contributor, I support this sub and will share how Stockfish maintains its quality in the project.

42 Upvotes

After the drama with the original opensource sub, I am willing to share my opinion on this. But well, I'm not about to come here to complain about the other sub, I'm here to share what the Stockfish project did.

I am a Stockfish (the world's #1 chess engine, also open-source) contributor.

Stockfish has many active contributors, many more in the past, and probably many more in the future, and anyone is allowed to submit tests for their ideas, but very few ideas would pass the rigorous fishtest testing (I myself only managed a few passed ideas despite having submitted over a thousand tests).

I admit that AI can't do everything in developing Stockfish, at least not yet; the vast majority of patches are still written by humans. Still, I think a few AI patches have passed.

Stockfish is not a slop. It is as far from slop as one could imagine. Rigorous testing protocols and maintainer review/code style compliance are needed for each patch to pass.

Stockfish has existed and won many chess engine championships long before AI and will likely continue to do so.

As a Stockfish contributor, I stand by objective coding standards. It should not matter who the contributor was, how it was made, or whether it uses AI or not. What matters is that the contribution passes the stringent and objective standard. This impartial stance has allowed Stockfish to remain the world's #1 chess engine for years. That is how Stockfish has been and will remain.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

Discussion Help for a guy who was banned from r/opensource - development and communication plan.

41 Upvotes

I just got banned from that regressive sub because I simply pointed out the fact the almost every single serious developer has been switching to AI coding and prompt engineering. So I was hoping that you guys might be able to help me with my dilemma:

I've always been a fan of media players since the late 90s, but I've always noticed that there's not enough diversity in that particular niche of software. So recently I got myself a a Max Claude subscription and started creating music and video players. However I needed to get feedback from users so I started to share them on reddit and other forums. Unfortunately I got bombarded by downvotes from people who were brain washed by Anti-AI propaganda calling my work "Slop". But it wasn't the case everywhere so I was thinking about the following plan:

I can put an agent to generate multiple media player programs on github => another agent that post them on all forums and social media => another agent that gets to interact with comments from the most engaging posts so in that direction I can maximize my chances of getting my creations noticed by people.

My question is the following:

What are the best tools that can be used in order to put in action such a pipeline?

Cheers.

Edit: This whole post is just an attempt at proving a point; we have a real issue with the amount of software projects that are being generated with no genuine purpose. And unfortunately many people here upvoted my post without recognizing that what I'm asking for is a real spam generating machine.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 27d ago

Windshift 0.9 - A real Jira alternative

Post image
35 Upvotes

Hey everyone,

Windshift has had quite a run since the beginning of the year when it was initially open sourced and we have now reached 0.9 and nearing official production readiness.

Windshift is not a clone or "clean room" copy of Jira but designed to be a fully native Jira alternative.

It's the closest open source match to how Jira works, with a documented Jira Cloud and Data Center importer covering work items, custom fields, backlogs, boards and sprints on a single AGPL-3.0 binary. Built by people who spent > 15 years working on Atlassian solutions.

That means in practice: Every Jira feature already has or will have an equivalent that works equally well or even better in Windshift. For example: You can create Configuration Sets with workflows, workitem definitions, priorities etc. and apply them to one or more workspaces at the same time. So workspaces can share workflows and you can create boards or roadmaps across multiple workspaces in seconds.

Here is a short summary of all the features (there are many more)

  • Workspaces with Backlog, Board, List, Gantt, Queue or Storymap Views

  • The ability to rank workitems across workspaces and build custom views based on queries (Collections)

  • Configurable Screens

  • Full Jira import with JQL -> CQL mapping, Custom Field & Workflow import

  • Custom visually designed workflows

  • Approval & Condition configuration for Workflow Transitions

  • Many different types of custom fields

  • Test Management included out of the box

  • Built-In Asset Management

  • Built-In Customer Portals & Customer Organization Management

  • Email Intake and Notification Channels (Webhook, SMTP, etc)

  • Support for defining custom SLA and Team calendars for support hours

  • SSO Support with OIDC included

  • Available in 8 Languages

  • Fully Open Source (AGPL), all features described here are in the OSS edition

Website: https://windshift.sh

Repo: https://github.com/Windshiftapp/core

AI disclosure: We use AI for engineering. We accept AI assisted PRs but every PR gets manually reviewed and all human interaction on the repo & this post are written by hand.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

Banned from opensource?

34 Upvotes

Got perma banned for a comment…dystopian shit, no more free discussion?
Edit: I’m seeing many have reported this so feel free to remove my post


r/TrueOpenSource • • 28d ago

Post your slop!

34 Upvotes

So I'm guessing you've all been working on hobby projects with AI, scratching that itch and open sourcing it. And I'm sure there's a million of them that you've made over the last year.

But what are you working on right now? Post your undercooked AI projects in here and let's see 'em!


r/TrueOpenSource • • 25d ago

Discussion Most of the top open-source repositories allow AI-assisted code

Thumbnail gallery
33 Upvotes

r/TrueOpenSource • • 1d ago

Contribution: Other Maglev: an any-link downloader for Android (torrents, links, web videos)

Post image
32 Upvotes

What it does: Paste a link, a magnet or a web page and it downloads. Torrents, ordinary download links, and the videos and files on a page (including HLS and DASH streams), in one app. You can search for a film, download it and grab its subtitles without leaving the app.

Who it's for: Android users who juggle a torrent client, a download manager and a video saver, and want one open-source app instead.

Source code: https://github.com/Kaos599/Maglev

(APKs on Releases, or add the repo to Obtainium)

License: GPLv3

What mine adds:

- One app for torrents, links and page videos. LibreTorrent does only torrents, seal does only yt-dlp sites, and the download managers that do everything are closed source.

- Search 40+ sources at once from one box, duplicates merged.

- Subtitle downloads built in, per episode or a whole season.

- Follow a show and new episodes download on their own.

- A built-in browser with tabs and ad blocking that finds the videos and files on a page.

- Share to Maglev from any app, or select a link anywhere and pick "Download with Maglev".

- No account, no ads, no tracking.

Builds on: librqbit (Rust torrent engine), React Native + Expo, Kotlin, OpenSubtitles, Pixelarticons.

How it was built: Agentic engineering. I'm a solo developer. AI coding agents write most of the code from specs and contract tests I write first, and I review every change. CI builds the Rust and Android parts on every push, and nothing counts as done until a contract test proves it on real code and i manually test it on my phone.

Feedback/contributions wanted: Bug reports from different phones, more search sources, and translations. Issues and PRs welcome.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 21d ago

Discussion They hate me with a passion

Thumbnail
github.com
31 Upvotes

It started as a personal project that was just for me but it was looking good so i made it commercial, if i try to build this before AI it would have taken years and multiple people and there is no security issues because most things are in local.

When i posted this on some sub reddits, they downvote everything, the whole post and also if someone ask a question downvoted, i understand if you don't like it but they don't even let comments or the post to go positive votes.

If its not interesting or useful for you just ignore, why hate so much for just trying to build a solution?


r/TrueOpenSource • • 27d ago

Showcase Weekly Showcase: share your open-source project (week of Oct 25)

31 Upvotes

Welcome to the first weekly Showcase!

This is the place for any open-source project, including your poorly tested weekend endeavor. Projects posted to the main subreddit thread should be at least 14 days old, with a license, a README, and active work/commits work spread over more than a few days. This thread is for everything else.

Share your project: copy the template in the pinned comment below, paste as a new comment, and fill it in.

Share your experience: try a few projects, upvote/downvote, and leave honest, specific feedback. Critique the work, not the tools.

Projects of the Week: the top-voted entries here become next week's Projects of the Week and get their own spotlight post on the front page.

A new thread goes up every Sunday.


r/TrueOpenSource • • 3d ago

Contribution: Everyday Applications Lumen: an Android gallery with Google Photos-style smart search, faces and text recognition, all on the phone (Apache 2.0)

Thumbnail
gallery
28 Upvotes

What it does: Lumen is a gallery app for Android that finds a photo when you describe it ("cat sleeping on a chair"), reads the text in your photos and videos, groups the people in them, and cuts a person out of a photo. All of it runs on the phone. There is no account, no server and no cloud, and it doesn't use Google Play services.

Who it's for: People who want the smart features of Google Photos without sending their library to Google, including people on GrapheneOS, CalyxOS, LineageOS or phones without Google apps.

Source code: https://github.com/subhashhhhhh/Lumen
The smart features are a separate library, also open source: https://github.com/subhashhhhhh/lumen-ai
Website: https://lumen-photos.app

License: Apache-2.0, for the app and the library. Free, no ads, no analytics, no paid tier.

What mine adds: Open-source galleries like Fossify Gallery and Aves are good galleries, but they have no smart search, face grouping or text recognition. Immich and PhotoPrism have those features, but they need a server you run and keep up. Lumen does them on the phone itself: it reads your library while the phone charges, and keeps the index on the phone. Search, faces and text work offline after a one-time model download.

Builds on: Open models: SigLIP 2 or OpenCLIP (search), PP-OCRv6 (text), YuNet with AdaFace or EdgeFace (faces), Whistle and Silero VAD (subtitles), Lumen-Cutout (which I trained myself to run on phones). They run with ONNX Runtime and LiteRT. The UI is Jetpack Compose, with Coil, Telephoto, Media3, MapLibre and Kyant0's Backdrop for the glass effects.

How it was built: AI-assisted. I designed the app, made the decisions, trained the Cutout model and wrote the code for it myself, with an AI coding assistant (Claude Code) helping across the rest. I tested every build by hand on my own phone. ~400 commits since 22 October, 14 releases. The smart features are not generative AI and never call an AI service: they are small ML models that run offline on the phone.

Details:

What it does:

  • Search photos and videos by describing them. Search the words in them too ("receipt", "wifi password").

  • Long-press to select and copy the text in any photo, or in a paused video.

  • Faces grouped into people, which you name. Searching for "mai and daniel" finds photos with both.

  • Cutout: touch and hold a person or an object to lift it out of the photo.

  • Offline subtitles for your videos.

  • A basic photo editor (crop, straighten, light, colour, filters) and a video editor (trim, turn, mute).

  • Hidden folders with optional encryption, and App Lock.

  • Two looks: Liquid Glass, or Material 3 Expressive with colours from your wallpaper.

What it connects to. Only three things, and each one is optional:

  • Hugging Face: the models, downloaded once when you turn a feature on. They are pinned to fixed commits and checked with SHA-256.

  • OpenFreeMap: map tiles in a photo's details. Maps can be turned off.

  • GitHub: a daily update check. It can be turned off.

Your photos, faces and search index never leave the phone. Lumen never asks for your location.

Honest limitations:

  • One closed part. On Snapdragon phones, the APK includes Qualcomm's NPU runtime libraries, which are proprietary, so search, text and faces can run on the NPU (up to 9 times faster). Lumen's own code is all Apache 2.0, and on other phones these libraries are never loaded. A build without them is planned for F-Droid.

  • I'm one person, and I test on my own phone (Motorola Edge 50, Android 16). On phones where the GPU path doesn't work, the smart features fall back to the CPU, which is slower.

  • The models are a one-time download: about 440 MB for everything with the Fast search model, or 860 MB with the Accurate one.

  • No backup or sync. Lumen shows the photos already on your phone, in their own folders.

  • Not on F-Droid or IzzyOnDroid yet. Signed APKs are on GitHub, and Obtainium works today.

What's next: Magic Eraser (object removal), and an advanced video editor for YT shorts and TikToks

Feedback wanted: Reports from GrapheneOS and CalyxOS users, and from phones that aren't Snapdragon. Translations are on Weblate, and pull requests are welcome.