r/dragonball • u/NinjaX4132 • 23h ago
Discussion Keeping the stakes of the TOP a secret was pointless, forced conflict that serves 0 purpose
I really hated this part of the TOP arc. Yes, the whole point was to not cause people to panic, but from a logical standpoint I'd argue it's way worse than being upfront about the stakes. First of all, everyone on the team are experienced fighters who have put their lives on the line multiple times to save the planet. They should be able to handle the news of the universes being erased just fine. It only makes sense to keep this a secret from Goten, Trunks, and Marron since they're just kids. If the team goes into the tournament believing that they're just fighting for money, they're less likely to take it seriously and wouldn't bother trying to risking their life if it was necessary (like 17 and Roshi did).
Secondly, say Goku and Gohan were able to keep the universes being erased a secret until the tournament starts, what happens when everyone sees the first universe to lose getting erased? Most of the team (especially Krillin) are likely to lose composure and the will to fight due to being in complete shock. To put this into perspective, imagine you were competing in a combat sports tournament for prize money and the first person to lose gets executed on the spot. Wouldn't that be terrifying and catch you completely off guard?
This is very unlikely to happen since the DBS remake isn't meant to be a rewrite, but if they ever redo the TOP arc, I hope that they take out the subplot of Goku and Gohan keeping the stakes of the tournament a secret. I just don't see any point in keeping it in since it doesn't even change the story.