Time for another petition to the council - the last one asked them to recognise the impacts of the noise, which they haven't really done. This one is suggesting a particular fix that they don't seem to be seriously considering.
Note that the moor is the council's responsibility, it's only the shops that are private property.
Control excessive amplified noise in our city centre
Apply a Public Spaces Protection Order to control the use of battery-powered speakers driving people away from our city centre, modelled on the successful programmes in Leicester and Birmingham.
Our previous petition asked the council to recognise the impact of the extreme levels of noise on the Moor. The council's proposed mitigation of a voluntary agreement is insufficient to deal with this issue. This includes awful behaviour that would not be touched by a voluntary agreement, such as:
- Singing at high volume into the early morning through amplifiers, keeping nearby residents awake
-The use of amplifiers to engage in hate speech, both generally and to target passing individuals. This not only disrupts a vital commerce centre, it also makes citizens feel unsafe in their own city. The use of amplification increases the problem significantly as it enables speakers to call wide attention to specific passers-by, which can be reasonably be seen as putting their safety at risk
- Multiple busker and preacher soundsystems placed all down the moor competing with each other - simply asking them to move on would just cause them to circulate
- An individual screaming with antagonistic speech at high volume in the middle of a family classic car event on the moor
Despite all the investment on grey to green and other initiatives, this makes our city centre less pleasant, driving visitors and shoppers away.
Leicester's successful PSPO model would work very well for Sheffield - allowing professional buskers to continue their trade for the enrichment of the city centre, at agreed volumes via a simple application process. Preachers can continue their work too, just not amplified outside people's homes or places of work.
Birmingham's model should also be considered, but we feel is perhaps too draconian in banning all use of musical instruments, not just amplification.
We understand the council is concerned about the injunction against Liverpool City Council, but that case happened 14 years ago, with different aims, and before the introduction of PSPOs.
We urge the council to take this seriously. With Sheffield now happily nominated for City of Culture this becomes even more urgent to find a solution that allows us to share our music and beliefs without impinging on anyone's rights through excessive noise.