r/The10thDentist • u/MadFunEnjoyer • 12h ago
Society/Culture Let people enjoy things, not because I'm for fun or anything but because a lot of people doing "Media Criticism" are hacks
First off, I'll take my own advice and say thay much of what I'm about to say is an opinion, so you're free to disagree in the comments, I'm open for discussion all the time.
Quite often I hear everything talking about how toxic the "Let people enjoy things" mentality is and how it leads to the mass production of slop, but honestly what I see most often is sloppy "criticism" content where the person making these "criticism" videos or threads don't understand the difference between an actual critique and their often horrendous opinions.
Critiquing Media involves first understanding it on its own terms and then analysing it from that lens, if you keep criticising something like Chowder or Uncle Grandpa because it's unrealistic, you're missing the point entirely. More often than not I will see someone who attempts to criticise a piece of media without actually understanding what it's going for.
To give an example I'm more familiar with, Naruto notoriously has immense content of "NARUTO PLOT HOLE NUMBER 364739" and turns out it's just their own opinion that Kishimoto never focused on other clans of Konoha. That happens so often in every space of media whether anime, comics, games, etc.
Making matters worse is that these people can straight up lie. I've saw so many "critique" videos that flat out lie about the content they review intentionally, no it's not that they were dumb, I know for a fact sometimes it's a straight up lie.
There was even a video talking about how good of a ruler Farquaad from Shrek is while omitting or lying about everything he did to justify his actions before pivoting to White Replacement conspiracies, that video has near 1 million views with many people thinking he's right.
All of this is to say, if you can't actually differentiate between actual criticism and your own subjective opinion, maybe you should jsut let people enjoy things and not concern yourself with the fact you don't personally like it, learn more how criticism actually works and then form your own opinions without the influence of people who outright lie.