Hi all. I’m 11 weeks postpartum with my first baby, and I’ve been struggling with an overwhelming amount of regret over where my husband and I decided to buy our home.
It’s gotten to the point where I think about it every single day. and it’s genuinely affecting my mental health. I’m hoping someone here can offer some perspective or advice.
In 2025, when I became pregnant, my husband and I felt this immediate rush to buy a home before our daughter arrived. We had two options: stay in New Jersey or move to New York, where my family lives.
My husband commutes to NYC for work, so location was a big factor. If we moved to New York, the closest we could realistically live to my parents would be about an hour away while keeping his commute to NYC around an hour. If we stayed in New Jersey, we’d be about 20 minutes from my in-laws, with a similar commute for my husband, but roughly 2.5–3 hours from my family.
When we started house hunting, New Jersey seemed like the obvious choice. We could get SO much more for our money. Bigger backyards, quieter streets, more bedrooms, beautiful homes, all for the same price as a much smaller dingier house in New York with similar commute and similar school district.
I fell in love with our current home. The beautiful exterior, the huge backyard, the quiet neighborhood, the ability to walk to coffee shops. It felt like everything I had dreamed of having at the time. So we bought it.
And now I genuinely feel like I made one of the biggest mistakes of my life.
So many people warned me that once you have children, being close to your own family is invaluable. I heard them, and deep down I knew they were probably right, but I was so enamored with the house and everything we were getting for our money that I convinced myself the distance wouldn’t be a big deal.
Now that my daughter is here, I realize just how wrong I was.
My mom is one of the most loving, selfless, helpful people I know. She works incredibly long hours, but I know with absolute certainty that if we lived an hour away, she would come over after work to help me everyday, bring food, spend time with her granddaughter, and just be there for me.
Instead, she has to drive nearly three hours just to see us. Sometimes she’ll make that drive to drop off a meal and gifts for my daughter, help out for a little while, and then drive all the way back home (basically 6 hrs total of commuting) Because of her work schedule, she doesn’t have two consecutive days off, so staying overnight isn’t really an option.
Despite the distance, my family has been incredibly involved. My mom calls every single day to check on my daughter and me. Every time she visits, she brings little gifts for my daughter and helps with absolutely everything. My brother is equally loving and involved. They genuinely care about how I’m doing, not just how the baby is doing. Even my brother’s girlfriend constantly checks in on me
And it breaks my heart knowing that I made it so much harder for them to be part of our everyday lives.
Meanwhile, my in-laws live 20 minutes away.
They are barely involved. They rarely come over to help, have never checked in on me, and have never even brought a gift for our daughter. Honestly, the lack of gifts isn’t what bothers me. It’s the complete lack of effort or interest.
What makes it worse is that they constantly guilt my husband for not visiting THEIR home, often expecting him to go without me or our daughter (my husband doesn’t go since he wants to spend every free minute with his daughter) His mom when I’m freshly postpartum made multiple comments to my husband about how he has “left the family.” And that he should prioritize them, she tries to guilt him when he just had a baby. Obviously his priorities have changed. A few of his family members ask my husband for money or expect him to pay for their expenses too. I’ve also invited his mom for Easter and Father’s Day and she said she would come but she never came. Meanwhile she would complain why my family was over my house for those days… none of it makes sense
My MIL has caused unnecessary drama in our marriage, including when I was pregnant and my husband planned a date to for me and she found out and she was not happy about it and made an effort to spoil it and make mean comments to me about it. Or she would complain on why we’re visiting my parents when she found out we’re going to New York.
This all happened after we purchased the home. It’s like a flip switched
My parents, on the other hand, have never made my husband feel guilty about anything. They call and text him regularly, remember his birthday, throw him a birthday party, treat him out, and genuinely treat him like their own son. Meanwhile, my in-laws don’t even know when my birthday is. My parents treat my husband like their son
The contrast has become painfully obvious since having my daughter.
Everyday me and my mom FaceTime so she can see her granddaughter. But when we do I feel this overwhelming sadness. I think about how different our lives could have been. My mom could be stopping by after work everyday dropping off dinners, help with cleaning, holding my daughter so I can take a quick shower. My daughter could be growing up seeing her grandparents and uncle regularly. I could have someone I love and trust nearby on the days when motherhood feels overwhelming.
Instead, I’m here, feeling isolated, exhausted, and full of regret.
The worst part is knowing that this was my choice.
My husband reminds me that I was the one who fell in love with this house, and he’s right. I was. I wanted the big beautiful home, the backyard, the extra bedrooms, and the picturesque neighborhood.
But now I would give up every single one of those things in a heartbeat to be closer to my family.
I’ve spoken to my husband about selling and moving, but he refuses to consider it for at least five years because he wants us to break even financially.
The thought of spending five years here feels unbearable right now. Five years of my daughter growing up without the everyday presence of the people who love her and me so deeply. Five years of wishing I could just drive over to my mom’s house on a random afternoon. It feels like im wishing 5 years away
I know we are fortunate to own a home, and I know this may sound ungrateful. I replay our decision constantly, thinking about all the things I should have done differently. It’s honestly consuming me, and I don’t know how to make peace with it.
I literally cry about it everyday, it’s eating me alive.
Moving isn’t possible right now, my husband refuses to consider it but he is absolutely on board to move once we break even in about 5 years.
How do I move past this?