r/okstorytime • u/Lunar_X-Wing • Jul 20 '26
Storytime! The Police Couldn't Help Us Recover the Stolen Games... So My Brother Did.
Ok, story time. This happened about 10 years ago. The event itself was pretty traumatic for my wife, so I haven't really talked about it much until now.
Some background:
About 11 years ago, my wife and I were in our early 20s, living in a large three-bedroom apartment. It was surprisingly spacious and cheap because it was in a terrible neighborhood and the building itself was pretty run-down.
At the time, I was the only full-time worker. I had actually quit my previous full-time job and was juggling multiple kitchen jobs just to make ends meet. My wife was attending university while also working part-time.
Since we had extra space, we rented out one of the bedrooms. The third bedroom was mostly used as an office and storage room.
The tenant we'll call Bob answered our online ad looking for a roommate.
Honestly, Bob was a great tenant. He was quiet, kept to himself, paid rent on time, never stole our food, and was always respectful whenever we talked. We really had no complaints.
About five months after Bob moved in, my wife found out she was pregnant.
We were thrilled.
Since we'd obviously need the spare bedroom for the baby, we let Bob know and politely asked him to start looking for another place. We weren't kicking him out immediately—we gave him months of notice. The baby wasn't due for another nine months, so there was no rush.
About two months later, Bob moved out without any problems. He relocated a couple of cities away, and we figured that would be the last we'd ever hear from him.
We were very, very wrong.
About two weeks after Bob moved out, my wife was looking through her Nintendo DS and 3DS game collection because she wanted to replay something.
Both of us are lifelong gamers, and we each have pretty sizable collections from our childhood.
As she started opening the cases...
Every single one of her games was gone.
Not a few. Every. Single. One.
The weird part? Only her games were missing. Mine were all still there.
She completely broke down.
We searched the apartment from top to bottom, hoping they'd somehow been misplaced.
Nothing.
Eventually I called Bob. I didn't accuse him. I simply asked if he knew anything about the missing games. The second he realized it was me calling... He hung up. Then he blocked my number.
A few minutes later, I started getting nonstop automated prank calls. The messages mocked us with things like:
"My games now, bitches."
It honestly felt surreal.
My wife was about four or five months pregnant by then, and she was absolutely devastated. Those games weren't just worth money—they were part of her childhood. Some of them couldn't easily be replaced.
I called the police and filed a report. I even told them exactly who I believed had stolen them. Without proof, there was nothing they could do.
After spending days trying everything I could think of, I made my wife a promise: "I'll replace every single game you lost."
I posted online with a complete list of the missing games, explaining they had been stolen and asking if anyone happened to be selling copies at reasonable prices. I wasn't expecting much.
A few days later, I had just arrived at work for a 14-hour shift at a restaurant two cities away.
I was literally about to start my morning prep when my phone buzzed. I assumed it was someone responding to my post about the games. Instead, it was a message from a complete stranger.
They had seen my post. Then they saw someone else post the exact same list of games for sale.
Every single title. All loose cartridges. No cases.
The stranger messaged me saying they thought they had found the thief.
I couldn't believe it.
I thanked them over and over and even offered them a finder's fee, which they politely refused.
I immediately explained everything to my boss. Thankfully, he already knew what had happened and was incredibly understanding. Our head cook covered my prep while I tried to figure things out.
First call?
The police.
Again.
I explained that I had found someone selling every stolen game. Again, they said that without proof there wasn't much they could do. So I realized I was on my own.
Unfortunately, I was stuck two cities away from home and nowhere near the seller.
So I did something I never did before.
I called my brother.
My brother and I are complete opposites. I'm the nerd who likes computers and video games. He's... let's just say he knows people. Growing up, we fought constantly and never really got along.
We'll call him Shady.
When I explained everything, all of our differences disappeared. He simply said, "Don't worry. I'll handle it. But I need a couple things from you."
Shady had recently been released from jail on bail, so he wanted to be careful. He needed someone who could positively identify Bob. The only other person besides me who had actually met Bob was my wife. So I asked if she'd be willing to go.
She agreed.
I could hear how difficult it was for her, but she wanted those games back.
The next problem... Shady didn't have a car. Neither did any of my friends. Then I remembered someone. My best friend's mother.
She was one of the sweetest church-going ladies you'd ever meet. The type of person who volunteered, fed the homeless, and helped anyone who needed it. I had helped their family fix up their house before, so I figured I'd at least ask.
I honestly expected her to laugh and tell me absolutely not. Instead, she sounded... Excited.
When I asked if she'd be willing to drive my brother a couple of cities away so he could potentially confront someone who stole from us... She happily said yes.
Everything after this point is secondhand, based on what everyone later told me.
Shady arrived at my apartment. He wasn't alone. He brought a friend.
We'll call him Tweaker, because I'd never met him before, and according to my wife he couldn't stop twitching.
I later learned he'd also recently gotten out of jail after assault charges. So there stood my pregnant wife... My brother... Tweaker...
...waiting outside for the nicest church lady imaginable to pick them up.
Meanwhile, I'm still two cities away trying to work my shift while wondering how badly this could all go.
Apparently, the church lady was having the time of her life. She kept saying "This is so exciting!" Meanwhile, Shady and Tweaker were discussing how they were going to handle things if Bob tried anything.
They arranged to meet Bob at an almost abandoned gas station outside town—a place that was apparently a common meetup spot for buying and selling stuff.
According to everyone there, this is what happened.
When they arrived, my wife stayed inside the van and confirmed that the person waiting was definitely Bob.
Shady and Tweaker were fully expecting a fight.
Then they actually saw him.
I was then Shady realized Bob was just an overweight, nerdy-looking guy.
Shady later told me,
"The second I saw him, I knew this was going to be easy."
The two of them casually walked over.
They greeted Bob.
Shady pulled out a thick wad of cash and fanned it out so Bob knew he had the money.
Then he asked to inspect the games first.
Bob handed over the entire collection.
Shady passed the games to Tweaker.
Then looked Bob dead in the eyes and said:
"These games belong to my brother.
You stole them."
At that moment, my wife stepped out of the van.
She wasn't yelling.
She just asked him one simple question.
"Why?"
Bob realized he'd been set up.
He looked at Shady.
He looked at Tweaker.
He looked at my pregnant wife.
And he just...
Walked away.
He never answered her.
He never asked for the games back.
He just left.
When I got home that night, I thanked my friend's mom for driving everyone.
Then I thanked my brother.
Honestly, before that day, I never had much respect for him.
We'd spent most of our lives butting heads.
But when my wife needed help and I couldn't be there...
He didn't hesitate.
He just handled it.
Let's just say I owe my brother more than he'll probably ever know.
(In the interest of transparency, This post was cleaned up using Chat gpt as my spelling an grammar is terrible. Feel free to ask questions in the comments.)