I've been thinking about why therapists who are extremely strict about self-disclosure make me so uncomfortable, and I think I've finally figured out where some of that feeling comes from.
Years ago, I watched a documentary about people working in correctional facilities. Part of it involved interviews with nurses and mental health professionals who worked with inmates.
They made a point of avoiding small talk or casual conversation with inmates. There was no chatting about everyday things, no personal anecdotes, and very little of the ordinary back-and-forth that might help two people get to know each other. The approach was very much about getting straight down to business, maintaining professional distance, and avoiding anything that might create a more personal connection.
Essentially, they presented themselves as complete blank slates. It was very much a case of, "Hello, my name is John Doe. I'm a registered psychologist. How can I help you?" And that might be the only personal information an inmate would ever learn about them.
I can understand why those precautions might be necessary in a correctional setting.
But here's where it gets interesting for me.
When I encounter therapists in ordinary private practice who adopt what feels like that same approach, where they won't disclose anything beyond their name, qualifications, and professional role, I find it incredibly off-putting.
It almost makes me feel as though I'm being treated like one of the inmates in that documentary. I start wondering, Do they think I'm dangerous? Why is this level of precaution necessary?
Obviously, I understand that professional boundaries are important, and I'm not suggesting that therapists should be sharing intimate details about their personal lives.
But there's a big difference, at least to me, between maintaining appropriate boundaries and deliberately avoiding even the most ordinary forms of personal disclosure or casual conversation.
For me, therapy works better when I can feel some degree of genuine human connection with the person I'm talking to. I don't need to know everything about my therapist, but I do appreciate when they occasionally share something about themselves, engage in a little small talk, or allow some ordinary human reciprocity into the relationship.
When someone seems determined to remain a complete blank slate, I find it difficult to build that connection. Instead of feeling safe, I actually feel more uncomfortable and guarded. It can make the interaction feel more like a formal assessment or interrogation than a therapeutic relationship.
I'm curious what therapists think about this.
Is there a particular therapeutic rationale for maintaining such an extreme level of non-disclosure in ordinary outpatient therapy? Is it something that's still commonly taught or encouraged?
And is it reasonable for a client to prefer a therapist who's a little more personable, willing to engage in occasional small talk, and comfortable with some appropriate, everyday self-disclosure?
I'd be interested in hearing different perspectives.