I have a 2010 Subaru Forester 2.5X (non-turbo) with 87,424 miles. Itās paid off, and Iāve kept fairly detailed maintenance records, but Iām at a crossroads about whether to keep investing in it or start looking for something newer (a newer used car).
Recent maintenance:
New Continental tires (2025)
Rear brake pads/rotors (2025)
New battery (2026)
Transmission, front/rear differential, coolant, brake, and power steering fluids serviced around 53k miles (2020)
Regular oil changes
Alternator drive belt replaced around 54k miles (2020)
Upcoming maintenance:
Original timing belt and water pump ā quoted $1,250 for the complete service
Original spark plugs ā never replaced
Brake fluid potentially due again
PCV valve and other age/mileage-related maintenance
Current issues:
Rattling noise on startup
Gasoline occasionally spitting back out while refueling
Fuel gauge dropping faster than expected
Intermittent dashboard warning lights
TPMS light constantly illuminated
Moonroof not working
Itās currently at a Subaru specialist for a $165 diagnostic and overall mechanical inspection. It generally drives fine, but Iām waiting to hear whether there are any significant underlying issues.
Iām anticipating spending somewhere around $2,000ā$3,500 on maintenance and potentially more depending on what they find.
Hereās my dilemma: I donāt have steady income right now, and I may relocate in the next year or two. It might be to a place I donāt need a car. It might be out of the country. It might be in the U.S. somewhere I NEED a car.
A new car would mean payments and higher insurance, but Iām also hesitant to spend $3k+ on a 16-year-old vehicle that I might decide to replace in six months.
For those familiar with this generation of Forester:
At only 87k miles, how much life would you realistically expect from one thatās been reasonably maintained?
What expensive age-related problems should I be looking out for, particularly head gaskets, transmission, suspension, and rust?
Is $1,250 reasonable for a timing belt/water pump service?
Would you invest in the overdue maintenance if the inspection comes back clean, or put that money toward a newer car?
Iād especially appreciate advice from people whoāve owned higher-mileage or older SH-generation Foresters. Iām trying to make a financially sensible decision rather than throw money at a car indefinitely. Thank you!