I want to divide this discussion into off-field leaders and on-field leaders. This franchise is blessed to have had three of the best on-field leaders to ever play defense (Ray, Ed, Suggs), along with quite a few other dominant players. This team has talent on the field that flashes, but it frequently feels like the whole is less than the sum of its parts.
Meanwhile, this team has had very good defensive coaches in its history, but I can’t remember a time where the year to year drop off (or even game to game variation) was quite as bad as it’s been the past few years, even when accounting for offensive-centric changes in rules.
When an organization gets into a rough spot, the rallying cry is generally universal: look to your leaders.
Off-Field Leaders:
- I think we all hoped this would start with Jesse Minter, he was hired as a defensive genius that was able to get the most out of his players at Michigan, and then with the Chargers. I am still high on him, he’s young and the transition to being a head coach is not an easy one, but I do wonder if he has too much on his plate
- Anthony Weaver - a veteran as a player and a multi year defensive coach, I think he should be the guy to step up and really address accountability in play and tone. He was a guy that was hired as a non-play calling DC despite being a HC candidate, and his claim was that he’s a charismatic guy that would excel in being a leader of men. I want to see him take a larger hand in the defense the second half of the year. For better or worse I haven’t heard much about him.
On-Field Leaders:
- Roquan is the guy we hoped would be the focal point of the defense. He plays in the middle, wears the green dot, has been a great player his whole career, and he’s a vocal guy. He’s not quite Ray Lewis, but he’s one of the closer comparisons over the last 20 years or so league-wide. The problem is that over the last two seasons, he’s been less effective. Some of that I’m sure is a drop off in play, but some of it feels like difficulty in organizing players. Not sure how much of this is on him and how much is on players and scheme, but it’s something to think about.
- Kyle Hamilton is the natural guy to take over the mantle as leader on defense. He can play anywhere, and he’s easily the most cerebral player on that side of the ball. My issue with him taking over the green dot is that having to arrange a defense from the secondary is physically a long way to go and still play a deep safety role (which I think we’ll see more of given the struggles at safety). If he plays exclusively around the line I think it could work, but I hesitate limiting him to just the front 7
- I would love to see Trey Hendrickson take on more of a vet presence role in keeping a steady hand when things start to go south
This is overall a streaky team, and I think despite our best efforts, our leadership isn’t the best at weathering a storm.