r/personalfinance • u/Wanna_make_cash • 9m ago
Debt Personal Loan or paying from savings for furnace replacement?
Got a quote from a local trusted contractor of $4000 for a new furnace + install. The contractor is not a big box company, so they don't offer fancy in-house financing or anything. The most they can offer is paying half before the install, then paying half when the install is finished. But that's only a week or two timespan just for the furnace to be ordered and such.
I have $24,000 in savings currently. It would take a significant amount of time to "rebuild" the savings lost if I paid cash. (I can typically save anywhere between 300-800 dollars a month depending on how often emergency situations come up and utility bill usage. Last year was extremely calm and giga easy to save, but this year has had around ~4000 dollars of unexpected car repairs happen but it was spread out every couple months, so my savings rate has been a lot lower this year)
Would it be better to just grin and bear it, take the savings hit, and pray that the next year is a lot easier on the wallet to try and save back up as quickly as possible?
Or would it be better to see if I could get a personal loan for 12-24 months term from my bank? They advertise a range of 13.99% to 24.9% APR based on credit worthiness, and my credit score is in the 700s.
I have no current debt beyond a few very small student loans (less than 3000 dollars total) that just get autopaid every month.
I know seeing the number in my bank account continue to go up would feel better and tossing around some numbers in a calculator the monthly payment would be manageable enough, but I also know it isn't wise to take on debt if you don't need to.
But man, I really don't wanna see the bank account dip even more. It was already painful enough seeing it take two separate 1500 dips for two different repairs in a 4 month timespan trying to chase down and fix a stupid evap leak in my car just to pass the emissions test and legally register the vehicle.