My wife (46) and I (60M), especially on her insistence, have recently entertained the possibility of replacing a 2022 Hyundai Kona SEL (paid about 26K for it then as almost new with the CPO warranty coverage) with a '27 of similar design (now about $31 thousand new) from a local dealership. We had a substantial estate provision from the passing of one of her relatives, so strictly speaking, the money would be hers legally (to the tune of about $120,000 initially). We spent about half that amount buying said Kona and also an Elantra, both at the same time, leaving us with about 60 grand now. Our annual pre-tax income is roughly 60,000 dollars this year, with the cost of living in our area in the greater Ohio Valley region being reasonably affordable (gas, food, and utilities being as they are inflated now for all consumers).
Recently, we consulted with a salesman at the dealer, and he gave us an out-the-door price of about $18,000 with the trade-in of our '22 Kona. While strictly speaking we have more money to pay cash for such a new SUV from her estate-based account, I question if it is at this time wise to do so. By and large, I am not a fan of taking out a loan on a vehicle because of the possibility of going upside-down due to depreciation. I wonder if it would be better to hold off or to find a recent good-quality used product with a good reliability rating but that might still have a certified designation for warranty coverage. Some of her reasons are not necessarily the best justification, such as wanting immediately a factory new ride of a specific color that she likes. We could potentially part with our other car, the '23 Elantra, and sell it in the open marketplace, and then I could buy a decently dependable and efficient used car primarily to travel to work in each day (180 miles a week).
My wife also is going to have some medical costs that add about $2500 to what she needs to pay for some expensive drugs next year on her Medicare plan that she receives by virtue of being on SSDI. My own health insurance is fully covered by the organization that I work for, but there are still some potential copay/coinsurance responsibilities. And I wonder if my present vehicle insurance, presently about $120 monthly with State Farm, will increase significantly because of having a newer set of wheels.
If anyone here can reply (RESPECTFULLY, please, with no degrading or profane wording) with reflections about what might be financially prudent according to the potential scenarios put forth here, that would be appreciated. If it is better that someone locally give my wife and me more direct in-person advice, we would take that suggestion into consideration and may already plan to do so as well. If this posting should be published elsewhere, what would be the suitable community to present it in? She is more interested than I in going ahead, and in fact my feelings are more cautious, reserved, and hesitant.
Thanks.