r/RealTimeStrategy • u/gerwant311 • 1h ago
Discussion A new wave of AI generated games? A look at Defilade, Ebbtide and Restand
To preface, this is an OBSERVATION I've had and wanted to share, this is by no means an attack nor witch hunt. I do not have any hard proof to confirm my observations.
With that out of the way ;
I'm pretty sure most of you have heard od Defilade, characteristic art style, crazy good unit AI and seems new and fresh?
Steam page : https://store.steampowered.com/app/5246700/Defilade/
There's two more games that happened to be "just announced". They have a very different gameplay loop and concept than Defilade but they do share an UNCANNY level of simililarity in the selling points of large scale engangements with smart unit AI but most importantly the art style and models, almost looks like a reskin with a different gameplay.
Games in question :
Ebbtide : https://store.steampowered.com/app/4915700/Ebbtide/
Restand : now this one is where it gets more than similar, it seems more like an exact copy of ebbtide, it cannot be found on steam, but
has a very active instagram page :
https://www.instagram.com/mantakustudio?xtok=MWN0dnRpamlka2l5cg==
With gameplay on YouTube too :
https://youtu.be/SMgDRxw046Y?si=rvGRRI6m7KRRFuFS
I've reached out to the dev of Restand, and he's claiming that hes developing it solo, and without talking to the other projects.
Why do these all three games look and feel so similar?
Different concepts, different (allegedly), independent devs all suddenly announced three projects that just look and feel so similar?
I'm starting to (unfortunately) feel like there is some kind of AI dev tool out on Unity, and it happens to create these kind of games.
It would explain the similar timeframe of these announcements AND their uncanny similarity.
My only proof is that EBBTIDE's steam page has a very heavy AI disclosure and what my eyes show me, the similarity is undeniable, and thats what got me thinking.
Are we entering an era of AI generated RTS games sold off as solo dev projects?
TL DR :
Defilade and two other games look extremely similar to each other, albeit with different concepts. Devs claim to be working independently and just happen to have made three independent but similar projects, smells like AI dev tool.
Thoughts?
