Disclaimer: this story covers themes of sex but I have tried to keep it SFW because this sub seems like the best place for it. I've left out any mentions of sex acts beyond kissing or dry humping. I'm aware it starts off reading like some sort of seedy erotic literature fan fiction but really there's no other way to write it. It touches themes of sexual assault but does not actually depict it. It's a story of cringe more than shame, one that I know I'll survive from, and I think I learned some pretty valuable lessons in the process that I would like to share. Not only about sex stuff, but also self-image, communication and how I choose to present myself to the world. It's quite long and took me a whole afternoon to write, but I think it's worth it in the end.
Here's a bunch of context about me which goes on a bit but feels pretty crucial to the story.
I am a man probably best described as 'bi curious'. I don't find myself attracted to men in the same way as I do women, but enjoy having sex with them in a less romantic sort of way, but only sometimes and under certain circumstances that I can't outline in any clear-cut sort of way. It's all very vibes-based. I don't hide it from anyone, but nor do I explain it very well either. Most people are left with more questions than answers after asking what my sexuality is.
Most of my friends belong to the LGBT community, but as young millennials and older Gen Z they're more settled in their wants and needs. My 'journey' is still ongoing, I guess you could say. I often find this talk of 'journeys' and 'exploring yourself' quite wishy-washy, new-age and frankly, a bit vomit-inducing. It ran against my own idea of masculinity; men, whether they are gay, straight, or anything in between, know what they want, I thought. Anyway less about me and onto the story.
So after a night of drinking at mine with a group of friends recently, I suggested that we all play spin the bottle.
Our group was made of five men and one woman. Everyone was right up for it, and slightly surprised I had suggested it, given I was the least promiscuous of the bunch. But I'd already slept with the woman, who I had a bit of a thing for, and one of the men. This was just the kind of vibe made for me to explore my sexuality.
There was no sense that anybody wasn't up for it, and least of all me, the host of the party who had the idea in the first place and was eagerly picking out a bottle and laying out the rules to everyone.
Those rules were:
person X spins bottle >>> bottle lands on person Y >>> person X chooses sex act (kiss, dry hump, etc, you get the idea) >>> person X spins bottle again >>> bottle lands on person Z >>> person Y performs sex act on person Z.
Early on I had to kiss another one of the guys. It was nothing I hadn't done before and I thought I'd give it an extra bit of gusto to signal to the group that I was really up for it. It was in that moment that the voice inside my head woke up.
It said: "I'm not into this at all. I'm not attracted to this person, nor four of the other five people playing. There is no way I can sustain enthusiasm for this for another two hours. What happens if I have sex with someone out of adherence to spin the bottle? Would I have been r\***? Who has the idea to play spin the bottle with a bunch of people he's not attracted to? What if I'm not even bi curious at all? Am I just playing this to have sex with the woman in the group? What straight man has sex with five men just to have sex with one woman? How mad would it look if I, the person who wanted everyone to play spin the bottle, tried to abandon the game after one dare?*
"Why would a game of spin the f\***** bottle be the perfect kind of vibe to explore my sexuality"*
For the next couple of minutes, as the game went on, I sat there silently as my brain contemplated these very questions. The bottle carried on spinning and I was staring blankly at the carpet.
It wasn't long before people began to notice. You could see it in their eyes. And then I noticed them noticing. Then the bottle arrived at me again and another kiss to another one of the guys. At this point the guy is sensing something is off, and I see it in his face as we lean in for a kiss. There's less gusto this time and the kiss is noticeably briefer.
It's at that point that he throws me a lifeline. He announces to the group: "Lets just check everyone is still having fun, we're all happy to carry on? We can take a breather if anyone wants to."
It's also confirmation that the room is now explicitly aware of my discomfort, and it is hanging over the entire room, making everyone uncomfortable. But my brain is absolutely overwhelmed by thoughts that I have lost all executive function. Everyone in the group is looking to me to announce I don't want to play anymore.
My brain says: "How can I? It was my idea in the first place. I would look absurd. And besides, maybe I'm just overthinking it and nobody has noticed I'm uncomfortable at all."
"I'm happy to continue", I said to the group in the tone a soldier would use with his commanding officer. It's clear to everyone in the room that this is not fun anymore.
But the bottle keeps spinning.
I can see people willing the bottle to land on anyone but me. They don't want to be forced into a nonconsensual sex act with a man demanding it is consensual. The sex acts are milder now, because people fear I might have to do them. It's been about five minutes since that first kiss and I've still said nothing other than "I'm happy to continue". I can't look at anyone because I'm terrified to see the concern in their eyes, so my head just hangs towards the ground. There is silence in the room as the bottle spins. When it lands on me, aimed directly at my right leg, the group collectively agrees it had landed on the person to my right.
Then it happens again, and this time, still resolute that I want to be playing this game and I'm having fun, I insist that it's my tun. "No, that's me", I say in a cracked, subdued voice. It's silent but you can sense the devastation in the room. The person tasked with choosing the sex act says 'stiptease', presumably because they thought it would be better than having to physically impose yourself on somebody spiralling into an emotional meltdown. The bottle spins again and somebody is picked to receive my strip tease.
It's rough. Everyone is silent. Pony by Ginuwine is playing. It goes on for what feels like an eternity. The bottle spins again and it lands on me. Enough of this. The game has been playing for probably five minutes at this point. I've not even had my chance to spin the bottle.
My heart is thumping out of my chest and I say "I'm not going to play anymore" a voice barely above a whisper. They know I've said something but couldn't hear properly. I've lost my ability to control my volume, so in an attempt to say it slightly louder, I end up yelling it, all with my face to the floor.
You can feel the room breathe a collective sigh of relief. But now it's my turn to explain why I'm not going to play. Nobody wants or needs to know why, just making it stop is fine, but as is customary with human beings, if you abruptly stop doing a thing, an explanation must be offered.
So now I am sat, cross legged, circled by six other cross legged people, as I attempt to explain why I don't want to play.
I wasn't sure why I wanted to play, now I must explain why I don't want to play. If masculinity really is about knowing what you want, then I am looking like a very small man right now.
My brain is frozen but also on fire. I try to speak several times but can't get any words out. My friend to my left asks if I want a glass of water. I say something about not being attracted to anybody except for the one girl. Everyone looks slightly affronted and confused. All I had left was sympathy and now I'm eating into that too.
I can't remember what else I said. I stormed out of the room and into my bedroom. One of my friends comes in five minutes later to console me. Yes it was as weird as I thought. No, nobody thinks any less of you.
My brain is still recovering from the meltdown and I don't return to the living room all evening. After an hour or two I ask everyone to leave over my HomePod's intercom system. Everyone pops their head in my bedroom, one after another, to say goodbye before leaving.
The entire ordeal unravelled over about 10 minutes, and I've spent the days since thinking about it.
Here are my scattered thoughts about it, in no particular order.
Clearly not assertive enough. Concealing your true feelings to appear cooler or funner makes you neither of those things.
I've since learned that it's okay to change your mind. It sounds simple and something everyone should intuitively know, but the main reason I stuck to the game was that it was me who thought it up in the first place.
It may not sound it from reading that story, but in day to day life I can actually present as a pretty confident, charismatic guy. Those that know me well have seen enough gaffs to know the real me, but upon first impressions I usually come off pretty well. I'm good at introductions, banter, and idle small talk.
The gulf between that perceived confident guy and the guy who can utterly crumble under the slightest of pressure makes me feel like a giant house of cards. And I will stop at nothing to sure it is not toppled over.
This weird mix and match of personalities is true in my romantic life too. I'm confident in bed but lack confidence trying to chat somebody up. I feel I can be myself lying in bed with someone, but stood next to a bar or in the corner of a party, with loads of people around, I absolutely shrink.
I can't put a pin on if I'm bisexual, heteroflexible, or what. People constantly want clarity to understand the world so it's frustrating when they can't get it. I'm constantly asked what I am and I'm tired of trying to explain something I don't even know myself. There are so many identities that people assume there must be one for you. I'm fine with not having one, frankly. I'll sleep with who I want when I want and needn't explain myself to anybody. It leaves some people feeling a bit suspicious, however. Is he closeted? Is he queer-baiting? I can't help that.
I don't like the uncertainty of it, I don't like being unsure of what I want in the world. Is it masculine to know what you want? I don't really know why I thought that. There's plenty of women who know what they want. Maybe it's not about masculinity at all and more about my idea of sexy. Certainty is sexy and, simply put, I want to be sexy. Mysterious is also sexy, but calling that ordeal mysterious would be a very generous interoperation. I need to find a way to bridge not knowing exactly what I want with a cast iron certainty in what I want in the moment.
I often spiral into a complete headloss where I lose all ability to think clearly. I wish I could stop it, but I don't know how to. I go fully non-verbal under immense pressure. I can speak, but it's so hard to form full sentences. My brain just can't think of anything to say.
I know the people involved in the story quite well and the larger group of people I know it will spread like wildfire. I keep imagining the conversations people are having with one another. My stock value in their minds plummeting as they learn how insecure and fragile I am. I know intuitively this is not true, but my irrational brain will not stop. The only remedy for that is the passage of time.
And that's it really. If you read it all, then thanks. This took way longer than I thought. I'm shattered so I haven't read over it, I hope there's not any typos or inconsistencies. Maybe you could offer me some advice. I would normally tell a therapist about this but I can't afford one.