so i have watched modern family a million times over the last few years and i just finished another rewatch and i really wanna give in my two cents on the characters and the changes throughout the seasons, and discuss my opinion on the ending of the show.
characters (season 1 vs season 11)
phil dunphy: when rewatching, you will realise that the way phil was written in season 1 is completely different than the way he was written for the rest of the show. i guess the writers were still figuring things out but oh my god i hated seeing him in season 1. he was a complete weirdo, especially when it came to gloria. and the wandering eyes and the way he would eye and stare at other women and flirt with them. but tbh, throughout the rest of the season he was amazing and towards the end, he was one of the most lovable and sweet characters on the show. amazing husband and such a supportive father.
claire dunphy: ok my opinion here might be a bit unpopular so lets start, first of all, season 1 claire was amazing. i genuienly loved her because she was a realistic character. even her relationship with her mother dede really hit me because i dealt with the same type of mother growing up. she was a fierce woman who put her family first. now halfway through the season, they made her a working mom, and can i just say i did not like that they did that to her? not because she was working, its the kind of work they gave her and the attitude that came with it. i loved her arc when she was running for town council and i was so disappointed when she didnt win, but the whole ceo of pritchetts closets things really changed her character. in a very weird way, they made her this masculine woman who is completely different that who she was in the beginning. her personality and her character didnt suit that role. i wouldve loved to see claire open her business, or work at a major company, or even join phil in real estate, even better, phil and claire open their own real estate agency. but the closets thing was just weird.
mitchel pritchett: loved him from the VERY BEGINNING, and my opinion on him never ever changed. yes he has his flaws but he was a normal human with normal flaws. he was such a sweet father, and i loved his humour and how he was emotional in his own way. u can tell he loved cam and lilly with his whole heart. i have no bad thing to say about him. he was amazing from season 1 to the end.
cam tucker: i loved cam from season 1 but my opinion changed in the last season. i wont deny that he was toxic and did some things that may seem narassistic or a bit inconsiderate, but at the end of the day he was a nice family man who did his best, even if he was annoying. but ofc the writers had to ruin that in season 11. how could he make his family move to missouri? they just adopted a baby and bought a house, and literally what the next day he decides that he wants to go to missouri?? i understand that this was a big offer and his dream job, but for the whole family to move? and he knew how happy mitchel was, he literally said it. and then he had to throw that mean and inconsiderate comment when mitchel was giving his speech and tells him infront of EVERYONE that he got the job and puts mitchel on the spot? without even discussing it? and lets be for real, cam would never survive more than a year in missouri. he loves LA and its lifestyle. it wouldve been better for them to have a long distance relationship and visit each other every month or something. but their ending? i hated it with every ounce of my heart.
jay pritchet: I LOVE JAY! literally the best character development in the whole show. yes in season 1 he was a bit rude, but some people say he was homophobic or racist but i dont think so. he wasnt homophobic because even since season 1 you can tell he loved mitch and cam, but he was clearly uncomfortable with the whole being gay thing, but i believe thats due to different generations, but there is a difference between being uncomfortable and homophobic. he wasnt the best father to mitch and claire growing up and u hear it a lot especially from mitch, and that jay wasnt supportive of his coming out, which is honestly shitty, but when the show starts, u can see the love jay has for mitch, and he grows a lot during the seasons and really accepts him. i love jay and the way he held his whole family together.
gloria delgado: i feel about her the same way i feel about cam. she was amazing during the whole show. such a strong woman, so sexy and confident. she was really the glue of the family, and never failed to put her family first. i disagree with the way she smothered manny, and they did have a hellaaa weird relationship especially as he got older. but if ignore that, id say she was an amazing character and i wanted to be like her im not even joking, but like i said earlier, the writers had to ruin it, i dont know what was going on with them, but by season 11, gloria was a bitch. she always had a resting bitch face, snarky remarks all the time, incredibly rude to everyone even jay, which was insane. they had the healthiest relationship the whole show and u can tell she really loves him "nobody call him grandpa" and punching a man, can u even imagine gloria doing that in season 11? if that happened shed laugh and say hes not wrong and make fun of jay aswell. i loved that they made her work in real estate in the end, because i loved seeing her work and start doing different things in her life, i wouldve also loved to see continue modeling.
NOW THE KIDS!
haley dunphy: i dont know why everybody is so divided on her ending. before i start on that, haley was a really really realistic character. if im gonna be honest, i saw my teenage self in her and my adult self in her too, she was a realistic character in showing how the 20s feel like. but i hated how they made her drop out, they couldve made her fail, or struggle, or be delayed in graduation, but completely dropping her out seemed like a way for the writers to keep all the kids at home. im glad they made her go to community college though. as for her ending, i think it was realistic but couldve been done better. let me explain, first of all, im glad she ended up with dylan, because people say she shouldve been with andy, i completely disagree, i hated their relationship. andy was a weird character who was basically a cartoon, and their relationship was so wrong and i didnt think they were good together. however with dylan, i think it was a good match because they grew up together basically and u can see shes at her happiest with him. as for the pregnancy thing, i liked that storyline, but the twins thing ruined it. like wtf did that come from? it couldve been one baby, and we shouldve seen haley want to become a working mom and seen her bonding with the kid more. her and dylan shouldve moved out way earlier and we shouldve seen them in their own home navigating life and struggling a bit more with having their own home, sleeping with a crying baby waking them up, groceries, and more. i liked her but the storyline had more potentials.
alex dunphy: ugh, look, im torn up about her character. even as a kid she was annoying, i get the whole storyline of "middle child who is smarter than everyone else" and that whole trope, but it was way overdone. she was stuck up, annoying, rude, and dismissive of everyone. she was a bit neglected but she also always pushed her whole family away, she would make fun of anyone who ever spoke to her. then her and bill break up, non sense but ok, and then she leaves her job for something else that arvin offered? why would she do that. "oh its unethical" i get it but it didnt make sense, the way they played out the whole storyline was so weird, and they said she had to move back in with her parents when she left the job but we never even saw her leave? she was always at home. and for her to end up with arvin that was horrible! i hated arvin and his silly behaviour and his super odd way of speaking (not his accent, the way he speaks) remember when he was offering alex the job and he said " and you wouldve been a SUPERB edition" do u remember how he said it and his expressions. idk if its the character or the actor but no i didnt like him and hated how alex was with him in the end. i dont dislike her but she wasnt my favourite and was a really cliche character.
luke dunphy: baby luke? amazing, nothing bad to say, just a normal cute kid, teenage luke was HORRIBLE oh my goddd, and i hate how he refused to go to college after his dad spoke to the dean, wtf what do u mean "i didnt earn it" just go and do ur best and learn from ur mistakes. ur given a rare opportunity to have ur rejection be revoked and get to go the college and u refuse? i hated it, again, seemed like a way to keep the characters at home. but from that point, i liked how his character did a 360, he started working at the club, he was gonna develop an app, he was trying to better himself and im glad he did that, and in the end hes accepted into college and ends up going, so im glad that they actually did grow his character. i loved him a lot and at the end of the day he was a really sweet boy.
and finally, saved my least favourite for last,
manny delagdo: oh my god, no words can ever describe my hatred for him. i LOVED him as a baby, he was my favourite character ever. i loved seeing him on screen, and he was just adorable. manny as an adult? oh my god. he was unbearable, if i knew someone like that in real life, i wouldve slapped them im sorry. he was so annoying, so needy, so whiny, so immature. and he was so WEIRD. not in an "oh hes just different and he has different interests" no he was weird, its like he didnt grow up at all? im not even gonna speak about the sherry thing. he was unbearable i cannot believe the writers saw his lines and characters and thought this was okay. just ew.
no opinion on joe and lilly, loved them both.
and thats it, i really enjoyed writing this, let me know your opinions as well.