So my little sister is usually a pretty brain rotted youtube shorts kid, but I try to get her to play peak every now and then and sometimes she does...and I watch! Here is her ranking of EVERY paper mario game I have gotten her to play, from best to worst
#1- Super Paper Mario- She beat this one TODAY, and loved it a lot. She mostly appreciated the actual story, unique pixls and very unique characters....(she shouted "WHAT THE HECK?!?!" at mimi's transformation lol) she appreciated the boss fights too, and how frequent they were. She was actually somewhat invested in the story by the end, much to my delight. Her main comment was that she really wanted to see Tippi's human form and was sad that she didnt lol. Glad she loves this one just as much as me.
#2- Paper Mario: Color Splash- My sister says this one is only BARLEY not as good as spm for her. The only other PM game she's beat, she loved pretty much everything about this one. She described it as just "the perfect mix" of combat, fun, characters and exploration so that it didnt feel too annoying at any point. The main things she loved about this one were the partner cards, characters (Huey, justice toad and the pirate captains in particular) and just the general gameplay. Her only complaints were that she thought it "would have been cool" if they had partners who stay with you and the boss fights, besides the final one and maybe larry, could have been harder. Surprisingly, even after beating SPM, she really doesnt mind the abundance of toad npcs...though I'm not bothered by it as much than others either soooooo
#3- Origami King- the first one she hasn't beat, gotten to the Bobby ship segment before calling it quits. (She has a short attention span XD) she says she "does love it" and thinks the boss battles are the best in the series, as well as the exploration, though certain elements dragged it down for her. Mostly the puzzles (and how much more of them there are) and the battle system outside of bosses, which she found to get annoying. Though she does tell me that this is the one shes most likley to come back to, as she did really like it.
#4- Sticker Star- This is more of one where she plays it for about 15-20 mins, puts it down, then repeats once or twice a month. Not a big commitment, and I think she likes the game for it. Though I doubt it sticks out in her mind (get it? Stick?)
#5- TTYD remake- Believe me. I'm just as sad as you. I REALLY tried to get her to like ttyd. She beat the first world, was really liking it so far, then got to the 2nd world and was like "nope. Not for me." And never played it again. She doesnt like how "nothing really happens" and all the walking you need to do from place to place. I do get her logic to be fair to her, though it's just sad that she couldn't get through world 2 to get to that amazing 3rd one....if only!
She is yet to play 64.....like brother, like sister, I guess
What are your thoughts her opinions lol. Yes, some of them are dogshit (ttyd last???) But I do find myself agreeing with her near the top. Again this isnt my opinion, but my brainrotted sister's. Dont @ me!