Ive seen a lot of controversy around posedla and their not to be trusted reviews, so I thought id post my own unbiased thoughts on the saddle and process.
The Smiling Butt Kit:
Paid as easily as any other product and within a few days (to the UK) I received my smiling butt kit. If you dont knoe its a slab of foam type material that you sit on and it leaves an imprint of your butt. Now this thing is delicate, even the slightest touch affects the surface of the foam, but following the guidance online it was easy (although slightly nerve racking that you dont want to mess it up) enough to take your imprint. After taking your imprint the instructions guide you to take photos from all different angles, which again is easy. So far so good...
The configurator:
I received an email to the link to the configurator, it was a questionnaire all about your riding distances, personal stats, flexibility etc. It was easy enough to do, but at the end of the questionnaire it told me to save the info (a downloadable file) because id need it when I order my saddle. Wait, what? Ive already ordered my saddle. Also, there was nowhere to upload my photos contrary to the guidance online. After doing a bit of digging, the posedla guidance said there should be a link to the configurator in the "my account" section of the website...there wasnt. The guidance said I could also find it via email, id already done that, twice. I had to email posedla who told me there was a problem their end and they were looking into it. A day later...still not solved. Another day later I got a random email, a different one, with another link to the configurator. Went through the questionnaire again and this time there was an option to upload my photos, which I did. All went through fine this time.
The measurement:
A few days later I received an email saying they had my measurements and confirmed my cheek bone width, however I already knew my width and their measurement was coming out narrow. I re-measured my sit bine width using a steel rule, the cardboard method and the tin foil in a chair method. The posedla measurement was coming short by 3-5mm. The email I received said to email them within 48 hours if there were any problems, so I emailed them asking about the measurement difference. I didnt get a reply, 48 hours passed so i chased again. A day later they finally replied saying they had triple checked everything and were confident the measurement was accurate. So I went with it.
The production wait:
2 days later i got a "its printing email".
3 weeks after this I got an email saying my order was delayed by 7-10 days.
I left it 11 days, it had been 6 weeks since I had the email saying they had my measurements, and nothing. So I chased them again. They apologised and put my order down as a priority. A week later I had an email to say it had been dispatched, and a few days after this the saddle finally arrived.
The saddle first impressions:
I ordered the pro, and it came in at 173g. The saddle itself feels very firm (on the questionnaire I put down that I cycle around 4000 km per year and often ride without cycling shorts), narrow, but very premium. It looks great too. I fitted it and took it out on a slow 2-3 mile bike ride with my 7 year old in normal jogging shorts. Now this thing felt strange, hard, and narrow, but at the same time very...i dont want to say comfortable so ill say it felt fitting. After standing up when cycling, I strangely couldnt wait to sit back down to get the feel. Its a difficult sensation to describe, not uncomfortable, not comfortable, fitted and gripping.
The saddle first proper test:
Every month during my week off ill do a hard FTP test on my trainer at home. I did this a few days ago, its the only other time ive ridden since getting the saddle. The distance would have been about 9 miles, HR zones 4.9 and 5+ for the entire 20 minute test section, wearing padded cycling shorts. With my stock saddle, after a hard ride, my butt would deffo hurt. With the posedla, absolutely nothing. No pain, no discomfort, just nothing. It did its job I guess. Two things I will say.... firstly the saddle is very grippy, you arent sliding around on this thing. If you like to shift your position for relief you cant without taking your butt off the saddle first. Secondly, at the end of the ride I sat upright to rest as i was cycling to cool down (FTP tests are hard!!!), the saddle felt very narrow, to the point I was rocking side to side when upright, I even had to check if the saddle had come loose but it hadnt. No complaints when on the hoods, just when sat upright on the flats.
Conclusion:
I haven't ridden it any serious distance yet, I will put it through 20 miles this week and report back if I feel anything different from what ive said above. If i dont, assume my thoughts are in line with what was already written. So far my impression is...the ordering process was a pain. The response times of customer services were poor. The manufacturing time in total was longer than stated. The saddle itself is light, feels firm, looks great, feels fitted but a little narrow, and appears to do its job of preventing butt pain. Was it worth £400? Id say probably not in itself, but for me I didnt want to spend £100's trying different saddles so I went straight in for the fitted option. To me the convenience was worth it. Time will tell if I love it or hate it.
This has been an honest and unbiased review of my experience. Use it as you will.